If you’re curious about ghost stories that aren’t just urban legends but backed by research and real evidence, the Shadows of the Supernatural Tour in St. Augustine might just catch your interest. Led by knowledgeable guides, this 1.5-hour walk takes you through some of the city’s most haunted spots—think cemeteries, historic buildings, and locations with documented paranormal activity. It’s a different kind of ghost tour, one rooted more in facts and investigations than spooky stories told for entertainment alone.
What we really love about this tour is how it balances history and ghostly encounters—you get a sense of what’s genuinely been explored and photographed, not just hearsay. Plus, the guides do a good job of making the experience feel safe and engaging, especially on a late-night walk. On the flip side, it’s worth noting that the tour covers some busy, noisy areas, which might make hearing every detail a bit tricky at times. Overall, if you’re into authentic stories and real evidence rather than just ghostly tales, this experience is well worth the $25.
Anyone interested in a thought-provoking, spooky adventure that’s suitable for curious adults and history buffs alike will probably find plenty to enjoy here. It’s especially good if you want to see a different side of St. Augustine after dark, with a focus on the city’s haunted past and paranormal investigations.
Key Points
- Authentic stories and evidence: The tour shares researched paranormal evidence, including photos and recordings.
- Guides make a difference: Knowledgeable guides like Bill and Nicolas keep the experience engaging and informative.
- Accessible location and timing: Starts at A1A Ale Works and ends at the Prince Murat House, perfect for easy navigation.
- Good value for money: At $25, it’s a solid way to learn about St. Augustine’s spooky side without breaking the bank.
- Suitable for most travelers: Most people can participate, and service animals are allowed.
- Late-night adventure: The 10:30 pm start makes for an atmospheric experience under the stars, though it can get lively with other city nightlife.
An Honest Look at the Itinerary
The tour begins at the A1A Ale Works Restaurant & Taproom and kicks off late in the evening, which adds to the eerie vibe. Over about an hour and a half, you’ll visit six different sites, each with its own haunted history and paranormal evidence.
Planning more time in St Augustine? We've covered other experiences worth considering.
Tolomato Cemetery
Your journey starts in Tolomato Cemetery, a place shrouded in ghostly tales. The guide describes its haunted history and shares paranormal evidence captured there. Visitors often find cemeteries to be naturally chilling, especially at night, and the stories about haunted graves add a layer of intrigue. One reviewer mentioned the paranormal evidence being presented made the experience more tangible.
Potter’s Wax Museum
Next, the tour moves past Potter’s Wax Museum, a building with a long-standing haunted reputation. Here, your guide talks about its spooky history and shares evidence collected during investigations. It’s a great stop because it combines a quirky historic attraction with ghostly stories, making it both fun and slightly spooky.
38 Cordova Street
At this spot, you’ll hear about the ghost girl haunting the Memories Room. The paranormal evidence shared here further immerses you in the story, and the personal experiences from investigators tend to make these legends feel more real. If you’re into ghost children tales, this is a highlight.
Casablanca Inn on the Bay
Moving on, you’ll pass by the Casablanca Inn, linked to Goold Butler, a figure said to haunt the hotel. That paranormal evidence adds a layer of authenticity, especially if you’re interested in haunted hotels and the stories behind them. Many reviews mention the stories about these spirits as a key part of the experience.
Oldest Wooden School House
This stop explores the school’s history and its ghost children. The paranormal evidence here is again presented by the guide, which can make you feel like part of an ongoing investigation. The building’s age and storytelling create a nostalgic yet spooky atmosphere.
Prince Murat House
Finally, the tour concludes at the Prince Murat House, home to the famous ghost of Faye Sheldon. As the most well-known spirit in St. Augustine, her story is a fitting end, with evidence adding credibility. The guide’s storytelling combines history with paranormal encounters, often leaving visitors intrigued and a little spooked.
What the Reviews Say
Reviewers consistently praise the knowledgeable guides—Bill and Nicolas—who make the storytelling lively and engaging. Multiple reviewers mention how they appreciated seeing photos, recordings, and evidence that backed up the stories. For example, one reviewer said, “Bill was an awesome guide. He was a bounty of knowledge and made the tour exciting,” while another appreciated the group’s ability to see real paranormal encounters.
Many travelers found the value for money excellent, with some describing it as a “great experience” for just $25. The late-night timing was also a hit, creating an atmospheric ambiance that’s hard to replicate during the day.
However, some reviews highlight potential downsides. A few found the tour too loud or crowded, making it hard to hear every detail. One reviewer even called it a “waste of money,” criticizing the focus on history over ghosts, but this seemed to be more an exception than the rule.
The Experience: What to Expect
You’ll start at the designated meeting point, where your guide will gather the group and prepare you for a walk that covers about six significant sites. The pace is manageable, with each stop lasting around 10 minutes—enough time to absorb the stories and paranormal evidence.
Throughout the tour, you’ll see photographs and listen to recordings that have captured spirits or unexplained noises. The guides actively share their own paranormal experiences, which adds a personal touch. Given the late hour, expect a quieter, more atmospheric walk—perfect for those into ghost stories or curious about the unexplained.
The tour is primarily on foot, so comfortable shoes are recommended. The group size is capped at 30 to keep things intimate and allow room for questions or interactions. Since it’s outdoors and walking through historical sites, light rain or weather conditions could affect your experience—be sure to check the forecast.
Is It Worth the Price?
At just $25, this tour offers a compelling mix of history, paranormal evidence, and storytelling. The fact that the sites have been researched and evidence shared during the tour makes it stand out from more theatrical ghost walks. If you’re genuinely interested in the haunted history of St. Augustine and want to see real evidence rather than just hear scary stories, this tour delivers.
Many travelers feel it’s a good value since they get to explore multiple haunted locations with a knowledgeable guide, hearing stories that are backed by investigation and proof. Plus, the late-night time adds an extra layer of ambiance that’s hard to beat.
Who Should Consider This Tour?
This experience is ideal for adventure seekers, history buffs, and ghost enthusiasts** who appreciate factual stories and paranormal evidence. If you’re someone who enjoys a spooky, atmospheric walk with a good blend of history and supernatural tales, you’ll likely find this tour rewarding.
It’s also suitable for most travelers, as most can participate, and service animals are allowed. However, if your main goal is a highly theatrical or purely entertainment-focused ghost tour, you might find other options in town more to your taste.
FAQ: Your Quick Guide to the Shadows of the Supernatural Tour
Is the tour suitable for children?
While most travelers can participate, it’s primarily geared toward adults interested in paranormal stories and history. The late-night timing and walking might be less appealing for very young children.
How long is the tour?
The tour lasts approximately 1 hour and 30 minutes, covering six sites with about 10 minutes at each stop.
Where does the tour start and end?
It begins at A1A Ale Works Restaurant & Taproom and finishes at the Prince Murat House, making it convenient to walk back or explore nearby afterward.
What kind of paranormal evidence is shared?
Expect to see photos, hear recordings, and hear stories of personal paranormal encounters from the guides.
Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, you can cancel for free up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.
What should I wear or bring?
Comfortable walking shoes are advisable. Since it’s outdoors, check the weather forecast and consider bringing a flashlight or water if needed.
10:30pm Shadows of the Supernatural Tour
“Bill was awesome. He was a bounty of knowledge and made the tour exciting. I would do this tour again.”
Final Thoughts
If you’re after an authentic, research-backed paranormal experience in St. Augustine, the Shadows of the Supernatural Tour offers a memorable way to explore the city’s haunted corners. The guides’ knowledge and the sharing of real evidence make it stand out among typical ghost walks. It’s especially suited to those who enjoy stories grounded in investigation rather than just urban legends.
The late-night setting adds a spooky atmosphere that’s perfect for a ghostly adventure. While some may find the crowds or noise distracting, most find the experience immersive and engaging. For the price—just $25—you’re getting a chance to uncover the haunted side of a historic city in a way that’s both fun and meaningful.
Whether you’re a skeptic or a believer, this tour invites you to see St. Augustine’s dark corners through a different lens—one of mystery, history, and genuine paranormal intrigue. It’s a solid pick for a unique evening out that combines storytelling with a touch of the unexplained.