Exploring Door County from the water offers a different perspective on this charming region, and a 3-hour private boat rental in Sister Bay might just be the highlight of your trip. Whether you’re traveling with friends, family, or a larger group, this experience provides both flexibility and comfort, making it an ideal way to enjoy Door County’s stunning shoreline and peaceful lakes.
What we particularly love about this rental is the modern, 2022-built pontoon boat — spacious, clean, and equipped with a hearty 150 horsepower engine that’s ready to take you where you want to go. Plus, the option to add water sports or a lily pad turns it into a fun, active adventure. On the downside, you might need a boat license if you’re the one driving, so that’s worth checking in advance if you’re not familiar with boat operation.
This experience suits groups looking for a relaxed, scenic outing with plenty of room for everyone. If you’re after a laid-back day on the water, soaking up gorgeous views and perhaps stopping for a swim, this rental can be a perfect fit. It’s also great for those who appreciate good customer service, as the reviews consistently praise the helpful, friendly staff.
Key Points
- Private group experience: Up to 15 people, making it perfect for families or friends traveling together.
- Modern, well-maintained boat: The 2022 tritoon is clean, spacious, and equipped with a strong engine.
- Flexible timing and options: 3 hours of cruising, with optional water sports to boost the fun.
- Easy booking and clear policies: Book 8 days in advance, with free cancellation up to 24 hours before.
- Scenic routes and stops: Cruise north to see white rock cliffs, Pebble Beach, or Horseshoe Island.
- Great reviews for service and scenery: Consistently high ratings, with many praising the staff and the views.
What to Expect When Renting a Boat in Sister Bay

Booking this 3-hour private boat rental in Sister Bay offers a straightforward way to enjoy Door County’s water scenery. The 25-foot pontoon boat, built in 2022, guarantees a fresh, comfortable experience. With space for up to 15 passengers, it’s a versatile option whether you’re with a big family, a group of friends, or organizing a special celebration.
Once you arrive at Northern Door County Boat Rental, the process is simple — they provide all life jackets for safety, and you just need to bring your good mood. The boat is equipped with a 150 HP engine, which offers enough power to cruise leisurely or explore more lively spots along the shoreline.
Enjoy being on the water? Here are other boat experiences we've looked into in Green Bay and Door County
The Start Point and Timing
Your adventure begins at 10967 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, with the rental starting at 9:00 am, which is perfect for daytime cruising. You’ll be on the water for approximately three hours, which strikes a nice balance — long enough to explore, but not so long that it becomes tiresome.
The Experience Itself
What makes this rental stand out is the freedom it offers. You are the captain — or can be, if you hold a boat license. If you don’t, don’t worry; you may be able to operate the boat with a temporary safety license, and the staff can help you navigate the process.
Travelers have highlighted how maneuvering in the harbor is made easy, thanks to attentive staff. One reviewer noted, “Taylor made maneuvering the dock in the harbor a breeze,” which speaks to the helpfulness and professionalism of the team.
Most groups choose to cruise north, enjoying views of white rock cliffs, or stopping at scenic spots like Pebble Beach and Horseshoe Island. Many reviews describe these stops as perfect for swimming and relaxing, with comments like “we stopped at Pebble Beach and then at Horseshoe Island, and we were able to swim and enjoy the beautiful lake.”
Water Sports and Add-Ons
The rental offers an add-on water sports package — including equipment for tubing or other water activities, and even a lily pad. These extras are ideal if you want more than just cruising, turning your outing into a lively day of water play. Based on reviews, many guests find these options enhance their trip and provide more opportunities for fun.
The Boat: Comfort and Convenience
This new, clean boat is designed for comfort and ease of use. The 2022 model feels fresh and well-maintained, which is always reassuring when you’re trusting a rental service. The boat features ample space for lounging, socializing, or enjoying meals and drinks on board.
The engine’s 150 HP allows for a smooth, steady cruise and enough power if you want to explore different parts of the lake quickly. For those concerned about safety, all passengers are provided with life jackets, and the staff is noted for their helpfulness and knowledge.
The Value of the Experience
At $260 for up to 15 people, this rental offers a pretty good value — especially considering you get exclusive access to a private boat for three hours, with the flexibility to go wherever you like. Compare that to the cost of multiple boat rentals or boat tours, and you’re getting a lot of space and privacy for your money.
Plus, reviews emphasize how “everything was perfect,” from the new equipment to the friendly staff, making the experience feel seamless and enjoyable.
The Experience’s Highlights

- Scenic cruising: The primary appeal is the chance to see Door County from the water, with views that are often described as “beautiful” or “amazing.” Many reviewers mention the white rock cliffs, Pebble Beach, and Horseshoe Island as favorite spots.
- Relaxed pace: The 3-hour window is great for a leisurely trip that’s not rushed. You can take your time to swim, relax, and enjoy the scenery.
- Good customer service: Multiple reviews comment on how helpful and friendly the staff is, making check-in, navigation, and questions easy to handle.
- Convenience and flexibility: With the ability to add water sports or choose shorter rental windows (like 90 minutes), the experience is adaptable to different plans or energy levels.
Possible Drawbacks or Considerations
While the overall experience is highly praised, there are a few considerations to keep in mind. First, boating licenses may be required for some operators, so if you’re not licensed, you might need to plan ahead to obtain a temporary one. It’s also worth noting that fuel surcharges are not included in the price, so extra costs may apply depending on your usage.
Weather plays a big role in water activities, and the rental is weather-dependent. If poor weather cancels your booking, you’ll be offered a different date or a full refund. It’s best to keep an eye on the forecast and plan accordingly.
Lastly, if you’re looking for a tour with more structured stops or guided narration, this self-guided rental isn’t the best fit. It’s all about your freedom to explore at your own pace.
Who This Experience Is Best For

This boat rental is ideal for groups craving a relaxed, scenic outing on the water. It suits those who want privacy, comfort, and the flexibility to choose what they see and do. It’s perfect for friends celebrating a weekend together, families wanting a peaceful day on the lake, or groups looking for a unique way to enjoy Door County’s natural beauty.
If you value excellent customer service, modern equipment, and stunning views, this rental will meet your expectations. Just remember, if you plan to drive, check whether you need a boating license first — it’s generally straightforward, with options for temporary licenses.
3-Hour Boat Rental up to 15 people
“Fantastic experience!”
FAQs
Do I need a boating license to rent and operate the boat?
Yes, a boating license may be required, especially if you plan to drive. Anyone born after January 1, 1989, is legally required to have a safety license, but obtaining a temporary license is easy and can be done at the rental location.
Can I add water sports to my rental?
Absolutely. You can upgrade your experience by adding water sports equipment or a lily pad, making your trip more active and fun.
What’s included in the rental price?
The rental fee covers the boat itself and all life jackets for safety. Fuel is not included and may incur an extra surcharge.
Where do I meet for the rental?
The meeting point is Northern Door County Boat Rental at 10967 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay. The activity starts at 9:00 am, and you’ll return to the same location.
How long in advance should I book?
The average booking window is about 8 days in advance, but it’s wise to reserve earlier during busy seasons or weekends to secure your spot.
What happens if the weather is bad?
If the weather cancels your trip, you’ll be offered a different date or a full refund. The rental is dependent on good weather conditions for safety and enjoyment.
In all, this boat rental offers a straightforward, enjoyable way to see Door County from the water. With modern gear, friendly service, and the chance to customize your trip with water sports, it’s a flexible choice for anyone wanting a memorable day on the lake. Whether you’re after peaceful scenery, fun with friends, or a family outing, it’s worth considering — just plan ahead for licensing and weather.
More Boat Tours & Cruises in Green Bay and Door County
More Tour Reviews in Green Bay and Door County
More Green Bay and Door County experiences we've covered
- Appleton Scavenger Hunt
- Experience the season with a scavenger hunt in Green Bay with Holly Jolly Hunt
- Sister Bay Shuffle Scavenger Hunt
- Green Bay City Segway Tour w/ Private Tour Option
- Appleton Scavenger Hunt by 3Quest Challenge
- Fun City Scavenger Hunt in Appleton by Operation City Quest
- Cave Point and Whitefish Bay Dunes State Park Ebike Rental
- Self-Guided Driving Tour at Door Countys Washington Island
- Baileys Harbor Lighthouses Segway Tour
- Door Countys Northern Peninsula: A Self-Guided Drive
- Fish Creek E-Scooter Guided Nature Glide w/ Private Tour Option
- Peninsula State Park Views Segway Tour w/ Private Tour Option
