Torrid Tales True Crime Walking Tour of St Augustine

The Torrid Tales True Crime Walking Tour of St. Augustine: An Honest Look

If you’re into true crime stories and local history, the Torrid Tales True Crime Walking Tour in St. Augustine might just be your next must-do. While I haven’t personally taken this particular tour, I’ve read plenty of firsthand reviews and details to give you a well-rounded picture. What makes this experience stand out is its focus on crime stories — from Florida’s oldest unsolved murder to recent cases caught on tape — woven into a walking tour through the historic streets of St. Augustine.

Two things we really appreciate about this tour are its small group size—limiting it to just 12 people—which keeps things intimate and allows for a more interactive experience, and the knowledgeable guides who seem to be well-versed in the town’s darker stories. On the flip side, one aspect to keep in mind is that this tour is rain or shine, so you’ll want to dress appropriately and be prepared for weather changes. This tour is best suited for adults or those over 15 with an interest in true crime and history, and it offers a different way to see and learn about St. Augustine beyond the usual sightseeing.

Key Points

• Small groups create a more personal experience
• In-depth crime stories from old to recent cases
• Knowledgeable guides provide detailed insights
• Tour is 90 minutes long, perfect for a quick, immersive experience
• End outside a local bar with optional further discussion
• Cost-effective at $30, offering good value for true crime aficionados

What to Expect from the Torrid Tales True Crime Tour

This walking tour is designed to walk you through the darker side of St. Augustine, focusing on notorious crimes and mysterious cases that have shaped the city’s reputation. Starting at 8:30 pm, it’s an evening adventure that lets you explore the city’s streets while hearing compelling stories of murder, justice, and unresolved mysteries.

The tour lasts about 90 minutes and involves walking through the historic streets, stopping at five significant locations that tell different parts of the crime stories. The small group size, capped at 12, ensures that everyone gets a chance to hear the stories and ask questions, which makes it far more engaging than a larger tour.

The tour ends outside Scarlett’s on Hypolita, where you’ll have the chance to go inside afterward if you want to chat more with your guide or share your thoughts. It’s a perfect way to wind down and reflect on what you’ve learned.

The Itinerary: A Closer Look at the Stops

Stop 1: 80 Charlotte St — Unsolved Crime

The tour kicks off at this address, where the first case has remained a mystery for nearly 240 years. It’s fascinating to think about how some crimes go cold for so long, especially in a city as historic as St. Augustine. The stop lasts around 15 minutes, giving you plenty of time to soak in the story and picture the scene.

Stop 2: 124 Charlotte St — A Solved Case

Here, the story takes a turn. This case has been resolved, providing a contrast to the unresolved mysteries and adding a bit of closure to the tour. It’s a reminder that justice, while sometimes elusive, can be achieved.

Stop 3: 210 St George St — Court Review of Two Unsolved Cases

This stop is particularly intriguing because it includes two cases, both unsolved, with a look at the courtroom proceedings. It’s a peek into the legal process and how some crimes remain shrouded in mystery. Spending about 15 minutes here allows you to consider the complexities involved.

Stop 4: 116a St George St — A Solved Crime

This location focuses on a case that was successfully closed, providing a satisfying ending to that story and a sense of justice being served. It’s a satisfying contrast to the earlier unresolved stories and helps balance the narrative.

Stop 5: 70 Hypolita St — The Recent, Hotly Debated Case

The final stop dives into the most recent case, captured on tape, which has sparked debate over truth and justice. This modern story adds a contemporary twist, and many find it especially compelling. You’ll spend about 15 minutes here, leaving you with plenty to ponder.

The Experience: What Makes This Tour Stand Out

The knowledge and enthusiasm of the guides are frequently praised in reviews. One reviewer called their guide “very knowledgeable about the entire town,” which enhances the storytelling and helps paint vivid pictures of each case. The intimate setting allows for questions and discussion, making it more than just listening — it’s engaging.

At $30 per person, this tour offers solid value, especially considering the depth of stories covered and the small group setting. Since no food or drinks are included, you’ll want to plan ahead—perhaps grab a bite or drink before or after the tour.

Rain or shine, the tour goes on, so dress accordingly. Many find that the evening timing adds to the spooky, mysterious atmosphere, making it feel even more authentic.

The Real Feedback from Participants

Readers have shared glowing reviews. One said, “Our experience was wonderful! Our tour guide was very knowledgeable about the entire town,” emphasizing the quality of the guide. Another noted, “It was a great tour! We didn’t want a ghost tour or pub crawl, and this one fit the bill,” highlighting its appeal to those seeking a more serious crime-focused experience. The consistent praise for the guide’s expertise and the tour’s storytelling approach suggests that it’s experienced quite positively by those interested in true crime.

Practical Details and Tips for Your Visit

The tour starts at 62 Charlotte St and ends at 70 Hypolita St, near Scarlett’s. The meeting point is central, and the tour is accessible for those with moderate physical fitness since there’s walking involved. Remember, it’s adults and teens over 15 only, so plan accordingly.

Since it’s booked on average 14 days in advance, it’s wise to reserve your spot early, especially during peak travel times. The flexible cancellation policy allows for full refunds if canceled at least 24 hours ahead, adding some peace of mind.

Final Thoughts: Is This Tour Worth It?

If you’re a true crime enthusiast or someone interested in the darker side of St. Augustine’s history, this tour offers an engaging, well-structured look at some of the city’s most gripping stories. The small-group format and knowledgeable guides make it a comfortable, interactive experience that stays lively even after 90 minutes.

However, if you’re not into crime stories or prefer daytime activities, this might not be the best fit. Also, be prepared for the weather since it’s rain or shine, and dress accordingly.

For those who want to add a different dimension to their visit — particularly if you appreciate storytelling, history, and a hint of suspense — this tour delivers a memorable experience without feeling overly commercial or superficial.

FAQ

Is the tour suitable for children?
This tour is recommended for ages 15 and up, mainly due to the mature nature of the crime stories. It’s best suited for teens and adults interested in true crime.

How long does the tour last?
Expect about 90 minutes of walking and storytelling, with stops at five different locations.

What is the group size?
The tour keeps it small, with a maximum of 12 travelers. This helps keep the experience intimate and interactive.

Where does the tour start and end?
It begins at 62 Charlotte St and ends near Scarlett’s on Hypolita St, where you can choose to go inside afterward for further discussion.

Is the tour outdoor, and do I need to prepare for weather?
Yes, it’s an outdoor walking tour. It runs rain or shine, so dress appropriately.

What’s included in the price?
The cost covers the guided tour led by a licensed and skilled guide. Food or drinks are not included, and gratuities are optional.

If you’re looking for a different way to explore St. Augustine and have a genuine interest in true crime stories, this tour could add an intriguing twist to your trip. It’s well-reviewed, reasonably priced, and offers a memorable night out, especially if you enjoy stories that make you question what’s real and what’s unresolved.