Gills Rock: Plum Island & Pilot Island Lighthouse Cruise

If you’re thinking about exploring Wisconsin’s famed Door County waters, the Plum Island & Pilot Island Lighthouse Cruise from Gills Rock deserves a spot on your radar. While we haven’t personally been on this exact tour, the reviews and details paint a pretty appealing picture. It’s a relatively short, 1.5-hour trip that offers a taste of the area’s maritime history and scenic beauty.

What really caught our eye are the excellent guides—people who clearly know their stuff—and the fantastic views from the upper deck. Plus, the tour’s reasonable price of around $47 per person makes it accessible for most travelers looking to get a dose of coastal charm without a hefty price tag. That said, it’s worth noting that the ride depends a lot on the weather, and sometimes, for safety reasons, tours might change course, so flexibility is key.

This tour is perfect for those who love a relaxed, informative outing and are interested in lighthouse history or simply enjoying the water. If you’re a maritime enthusiast or traveling with a group that appreciates history and scenic views, this could be a great addition to your Door County itinerary.

Key Points

• Short and Sweet: At 1.5 hours, it’s a manageable outing, ideal for fitting into a day of exploring Door County.
• Informed Guides: Guides are praised for their knowledge, making the experience both educational and engaging.
• Great Views: The upper deck provides excellent vantage points for photos and sightseeing.
• Historical Highlights: Learn about local maritime stories, shipwrecks, and lighthouse history.
• Flexible Seating: You can sit outdoors, in the interior cabin, or move around once underway.
• Weather dependent: Be prepared for possible schedule changes or rerouting due to weather conditions.

You can check availability for your dates here:

What to Expect on the Cruise

The Gills Rock: Plum Island & Pilot Island Lighthouse Cruise takes you through the historic waters of Door County, starting at Gills Rock. The journey heads north into the Porte des Morts passage, better known as Death’s Door, renowned for its treacherous past and shipwreck lore.

The boat is a 75-passenger double-decker vessel, giving plenty of room for everyone to spread out and enjoy the scenery. The lower deck offers outdoor seating, which is perfect for snapping photos and feeling the breeze, while the interior cabin provides a sheltered spot if the weather turns brisk.

Once underway, the guides and captain will share stories about the area’s maritime past, focusing on the lighthouses and notable shipwrecks. You’ll get close-up views of Plum Island Lighthouse and Pilot Island Lighthouse, both iconic structures that have guided sailors for generations.

Many reviewers have highlighted the smooth ride and the interesting narration that made the time fly by. One guest called the experience “friendly and very informative,” praising the captain’s storytelling skills and the clear, engaging commentary.

The Highlights of the Tour

Seeing the Lighthouses Up Close

The main draw is undoubtedly the Plum Island Lighthouse and Pilot Island Lighthouse. These structures are not just photo ops—they’re symbols of the area’s maritime bravery and resilience. The guides typically provide background about their construction, purpose, and the stories behind shipwrecks in the area.

Scenic Waterways

Navigating through Death’s Door, the narrow, historically dangerous passage, you’ll see stunning views of the surrounding waters, Washington Island, and the shoreline bluffs. It’s a calm, peaceful ride but also a reminder of the area’s wild, sometimes unforgiving nature.

More Great Tours Nearby

Learning Maritime History

The guides are well-regarded for their storytelling. As one review notes, “the narration was very interesting,” adding depth to what could be just a pretty boat ride. You’ll learn about legends, shipwrecks, and the evolution of lighthouse technology here.

Flexible Seating and Comfort

Whether you prefer the open air or a sheltered space, you’ll find comfortable seating options. The upper deck is perfect for unobstructed views, but the interior cabin offers a cozy spot if you’re sensitive to wind or cool weather. Once underway, you’re free to move around, which keeps the experience dynamic.

The Booking and Practicalities

The ticket price of $47 per person offers good value considering the guided nature of the trip and the views you’ll enjoy. It includes your ticket, a knowledgeable tour guide, and the captain who keeps the boat moving smoothly.

You’ll want to arrive at least 30 minutes early to check in and find your spot. The meeting point is clearly marked across from Charlie’s Smokehouse in Gills Rock—easy to find thanks to the signs. Parking is available in the designated lot, which is convenient.

The cruise runs mostly in the afternoon, making it a perfect way to wind down your day. It’s wheelchair accessible, making it a good option for travelers with mobility needs. Be sure to dress appropriately—the water cools things off quickly, so a sweatshirt or jacket is recommended, even in summer.

Considering the Weather

Weather is a key factor here. Several reviews mention that tour rerouting can occur if winds are too strong, which is a safety measure. One traveler noted, “we had to do a different tour because the wind was too strong,” but still found the alternative tour enjoyable and informative. It’s a reminder to stay flexible and check the forecast before booking.

Authentic Perspectives from Reviewers

A couple of reviews give us a good sense of what to expect. One guest raved, “Great information and relaxing ride, perfect weather,” which highlights how much good weather enhances the experience. Another called the ride “very smooth,” emphasizing the comfortable travel.

The guides’ knowledge and storytelling seem to be the highlight for most. They add a layer of depth to what might otherwise be a straightforward boat trip, making it both educational and relaxing.

Why This Tour Might Be Right for You

This cruise is ideal if you’re after a relaxed, scenic experience with a touch of history. It suits travelers interested in lighthouses, maritime stories, or simply those wanting a peaceful boat ride with beautiful views. It’s not overly long, making it perfect for combining with other activities in Door County.

If you’re traveling with people who enjoy storytelling and sightseeing but aren’t looking for a strenuous activity, this tour fits the bill. It’s also well-priced for what you get — good guides, scenic views, and an easy, manageable time on the water.

Who Should Think Twice

If weather is a concern or if you’re prone to seasickness, this might not be your ideal outing. Also, if you’re looking for a more in-depth or longer cruise experience, this 1.5-hour trip is just a taste. Finally, since food and drinks aren’t included, plan to grab a snack before or after.

Final Thoughts

The Gills Rock: Plum Island & Pilot Island Lighthouse Cruise offers a solid, straightforward way to see some of Door County’s most iconic lighthouse landmarks while learning a bit about the area’s maritime past. The combination of knowledgeable guides, scenic vistas, and flexible seating options makes it a travel-friendly choice, especially in good weather.

It’s a trip that rewards patience and curiosity. If you appreciate storytelling, beautiful water views, and a relaxed pace, you’ll likely enjoy this tour. The fair price point makes it accessible, and the friendly guides and smooth ride mean you’ll probably walk away with some great photos and a few new stories to tell.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this tour suitable for children?
While the tour is open to all ages, it’s best suited for those who can comfortably sit and enjoy the ride. The scenery and storytelling make it engaging, but for very young children, consider their comfort with boat rides and weather conditions.

How long does the tour last?
The cruise is 1.5 hours, making it a manageable outing, especially when paired with other activities in Door County.

What should I wear?
Dress for the weather—layering is recommended. Even in summer, it can cool off on the water, so bring a sweatshirt or jacket.

Can I sit outside during the cruise?
Yes, outdoor seating is available on the lower deck, perfect for photos and feeling the breeze. You’re free to move around once underway.

Is the tour wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the experience provider states the tour is wheelchair accessible.

Can I cancel my booking?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, which offers some peace of mind if your plans change.

If you’re after a relaxed, scenic way to explore the maritime side of Door County, this cruise seems like a solid choice. It balances educational storytelling with beautiful views, all at an accessible price. Just keep an eye on the weather, and you’re set for a pleasant outing.

You can check availability for your dates here: