Key West: Bone Island Haunted Pub Crawl

If you’re heading to Key West and looking for something a little different—something with a dash of ghostly intrigue—then the Bone Island Haunted Pub Crawl might just be your ticket. We haven’t done this tour ourselves, but from what’s shared by travelers and the comprehensive details available, it sounds like a fun, atmospheric way to spend an evening exploring the dark, haunted corners of Old Town.

What we love about this experience is how it combines history, storytelling, and a lively pub atmosphere—all wrapped into a two-hour walk through some of Key West’s most haunted spots. Plus, the inclusion of a souvenir T-shirt makes it a tangible memory of your spooky adventure.

That said, a potential consideration is that the tour doesn’t include food or drinks, so if you’re hoping for more of a drinking experience, you’ll need to plan accordingly. Also, it’s not suitable for those under 21, which is something to keep in mind if you’re traveling with younger folks. This tour seems best suited for those who enjoy ghost stories, history, and a bit of a spooky vibe—perfect for thrill-seekers and history buffs alike.

Key Points

• Guided Walking Tour: A 2-hour stroll into some of Key West’s most haunted bars.
• Historical Tales: The guide shares stories of murder, voodoo, cursed treasure, and unexplained deaths.
• Pub Visits: Three haunted pubs included, each with its own dark past.
• Memorabilia: You’ll leave with a souvenir T-shirt commemorating your spooky night.
• No Food or Drinks Included: You’ll need to purchase your own cocktails if you want drinks along the way.
• Accessibility: The tour is wheelchair accessible but involves some walking, so consider mobility needs.

You can check availability for your dates here:

What to Expect on the Haunted Pub Crawl

When you sign up for this tour, you’re signing up for more than just a pub crawl. It’s a ghost-themed adventure that takes you into the depths of Key West’s haunting secrets. The tour lasts about two hours, usually in the evening, which makes it perfect for after sunset when the spooky vibes are at their peak.

Starting Point and Meeting: Be sure to arrive 15 minutes early—timing is crucial for getting the full experience. The walk itself is a manageable pace, but be prepared for some steps and a fair amount of strolling through Old Town. The group size isn’t specified, but tours like this typically keep things intimate enough for storytelling, yet lively enough to feel communal.

The Haunted Bars and Stories

You’ll visit three haunted pubs, each with its own atmosphere and stories. These are places where history and ghost lore collide, and your guide will share tales of murder, suicide, haunted mansions, voodoo curses, and unexplained deaths. We loved the way the guide’s storytelling brings the history to life—there’s a certain thrill in hearing about cursed treasure or ghostly apparitions while sitting in a dimly lit pub.

One reviewer noted that their guide, Gene, was “friendly, funny, and very knowledgeable,” which adds a lot to the experience. Others appreciated hearing stories they hadn’t encountered before, making the stops memorable beyond just the spooky tales.

Atmosphere and Vibe

The pubs themselves are part of the fun—they’re historic venues that exude character, and their haunted reputations add an extra layer of intrigue. While the tour is primarily about storytelling and atmosphere, some may wish for more of a bar crawl experience with drinks included. As one person said, it was more of a history lesson than a typical pub crawl, but that actually enhances the storytelling element.

Ghostly Encounters and Reality

Although no ghost sightings are guaranteed, the stories and setting create a compelling ghostly atmosphere. Some reviews mention that spirits weren’t seen, but the enjoyment is in the storytelling and the ambiance. This makes it an intriguing option for those who love a good ghost story and a taste of the mysterious.

More Great Tours Nearby

The Souvenir and End of Tour

The souvenir T-shirt is a nice touch, allowing you to remember the night. After the tour, you’re dropped off in the heart of downtown Key West where you’re free to explore more or grab a drink at your leisure.

Is It Worth the Price?

At $32 per person, this tour offers a lot of value—guided storytelling, three haunted pubs, a souvenir T-shirt, and a chance to explore Old Town in a unique way. It’s an affordable way to add some spooky fun to your evening, especially if you’re interested in the history and legends of Key West.

While drinks are not included, you’ll have the opportunity to purchase cocktails along the way, if you wish. Even without alcohol, the stories and atmosphere make it a memorable experience.

The Experience from a Traveler’s Perspective

From reviews, it’s clear that knowledgeable guides make a big difference. Guests speak highly of Gene, finding him friendly, funny, and full of interesting stories. One person said, “We enjoyed learning more about Key West while having fun too,” which sums up the vibe well.

Another reviewer reflected that although it wasn’t a wild pub crawl, the focus on history and storytelling created a charming, intriguing experience. The fact that it’s wheelchair accessible broadens its appeal, but be aware that there is some walking involved.

The spirits of the past are what make this tour a hit. Whether or not you believe in ghosts, the stories are engaging, and the historic pubs add a unique atmosphere that you won’t find just walking around by yourself.

Practical Details and Tips

• Meeting Point: Arrive 15 minutes early to ensure you don’t miss the start.
• Duration: About 2 hours, usually in the evening.
• Price: $32 per person, worth it for the storytelling and atmosphere.
• Included: Guided tour, entrance fees to pubs, souvenir T-shirt.
• Exclusions: Food and drinks, so plan for that.
• Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible, but expect some walking.
• Age Restrictions: Not suitable for those under 21, so plan accordingly.
• Cancellation: Cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund—flexibility is a plus.

Who Should Consider This Tour?

This tour is perfect if you enjoy ghost stories or historic tales with a spooky twist. It’s especially appealing for those who want a relaxed, guided experience rather than a noisy bar hop. History buffs who enjoy chilling legends will appreciate the storytelling, while casual travelers looking for a different way to explore Old Town will find it engaging. It’s less about drinking and more about atmosphere and stories, making it suitable for those with a curiosity about Key West’s darker side.

Final Thoughts: Is It Right for You?

The Bone Island Haunted Pub Crawl offers a fun, atmospheric peek into Key West’s haunted past. With friendly guides and immersive storytelling, it provides a memorable evening that balances history and entertainment. It’s a great choice for travelers who love stories of the mysterious, enjoy a little spooky vibe, or simply want to see a different side of Old Town.

While it might not satisfy those looking for a raucous party or an all-you-can-drink pub crawl, it excels at creating a compelling narrative experience. The price is reasonable, considering the guided storytelling, access to historic pubs, and the souvenir.

If you’re after something uniquely local, mildly spooky, and full of intriguing tales, this tour is likely to deliver the right kind of thrill. Just remember to come with an open mind, some comfortable shoes, and a sense of adventure.

FAQ

Is this tour suitable for children?
No, it’s not suitable for those under 21, as alcohol is involved and the stories can be quite dark.

How long is the tour?
It lasts approximately 2 hours, typically in the evening, making it a perfect after-dinner activity.

Are drinks included?
No, drinks are not included, but cocktails are available for purchase at the pubs visited.

Is the tour wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the tour is wheelchair accessible, but be prepared for some walking.

Do I need to book in advance?
Yes, it’s recommended to reserve your spot ahead of time, especially during peak seasons.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.

What should I bring?
Bring your ID, comfortable shoes, and perhaps a camera to capture the spooky atmosphere.

This haunted pub crawl isn’t just about ghost stories—it’s about experiencing a side of Key West that few visitors see, through stories, history, and a bit of fun. Whether you’re a believer or just a curious soul, it’s a memorable way to spend an evening on Bone Island.

You can check availability for your dates here: