Exploring the Catalina Crusade Scavenger Hunt: A Fresh Take on Island Adventures

If you’re looking for a different way to experience Catalina Island beyond the usual sightseeing, the Catalina Crusade Scavenger Hunt might just be worth considering. While I haven’t done this particular activity myself, I’ve looked into what makes it stand out—and it’s definitely different from your standard guided tour.
What I really like about this experience is its interactive, tech-savvy approach—a remote live host guides you via your phone, making it feel modern and adaptable. Plus, it’s designed to be creative and fun, encouraging participants to explore hidden gems while solving clues and completing challenges. However, it’s not a typical tour where everything is laid out for you; it requires a bit of initiative and a smartphone with GPS, so be ready for a more hands-on, playful day.
This kind of adventure suits groups of friends, families, or corporate teams eager for something memorable and different. If you’re a fan of puzzles, art, history, or just want to add a dash of spontaneity to your island visit, this could be a good fit. That said, if you’re expecting a deep historical overview of Catalina, this might not satisfy that specific craving—it’s more about discovery and interaction.
Key Points

- Unique remote host experience offering real-time encouragement and help
- Creative challenges and clues that make the exploration engaging
- Suitable for families and dog-friendly outings
- Good value at around $23.20 per person for a 2-hour adventure
- Perfect for groups, team-building, or curious travelers looking for something different
- Requires a smartphone with GPS and a domestic phone number for best experience
Planning more time in Catalina Island? We've covered other experiences worth considering.
What This Experience Is All About

The Catalina Crusade Scavenger Hunt is designed to turn your typical island visit into a playful, interactive quest. Starting at the Catalina Coffee & Cookie Co., you’ll receive your digital quest from a live, remote host. This host acts as your guide, cheerleader, and puzzle-solver as you set out to explore Avalon’s streets and hidden corners.
The two-hour duration ensures you get a good taste of Catalina’s quirkiest spots without feeling rushed. You’ll walk or drive between various carefully chosen checkpoints, each with its own set of clues, challenges, or photo tasks that you solve or complete along the way. The game is structured to be flexible—you can hop in and out of indoor and outdoor locations—making it a dynamic experience regardless of weather or your pace.
What makes this adventure particularly appealing is the ability to connect with locals, who may be part of your clues, and to share photos and videos with your remote host. This interactive element adds a layer of fun and engagement that’s different from just wandering around with a map.
The Flow of the Day: What to Expect

Your journey kicks off at the cozy Catalina Coffee & Cookie Co., a spot that’s both scenic and friendly—a perfect starting point. From here, your host sends you the first clues and challenges. The locations you’ll visit are a mix of Avalon’s scenic spots and lesser-known corners, offering an authentic feel of Catalina beyond the tourist trail.
One of the highlights is the variety of challenges, which are designed to get you outside your comfort zone—think quirky photo challenges, mini puzzles, or even interacting with locals. The challenges vary from accepting wacky tasks to interpreting art or history clues creatively. The goal isn’t just to race against others (even if your score is posted on an international leaderboard), but to have a good time and discover some little-known gems.
The review mentions that most travelers find the game easily walkable within a small radius, which is helpful if you’re traveling with kids or prefer a leisurely pace. The experience is family and dog friendly, so everyone can join in the fun. The host stays in contact via texts, cheering you on, providing hints when needed, and helping you stay on track.
How the Tour Unfolds in Practice

While the specifics can vary depending on your team and how you approach it, a typical session involves:
- Starting at the meeting point: The Catalina Coffee & Cookie Co., where you get your first instructions.
- Receiving your digital quest: From your remote host, who guides you through each step.
- Walking or driving between checkpoints: Each location offers its own set of clues or challenges.
- Taking photos or videos: These get sent to your host, who responds with encouragement and additional hints.
- Interacting with locals: To solve certain clues—adding an element of social engagement.
- Completing challenges: From simple photo tasks to wacky activities, making the experience lively and memorable.
- Returning to the start: The activity ends back where it began, leaving you with stories and perhaps some new secret spots learned along the way.
The mix of indoor and outdoor activity keeps things lively, and the flexibility means you can tailor it to your group’s energy and interests.
What Real Participants Say
Based on reviews, opinions are mixed but mostly positive. One reviewer felt that $75 was too much for what was received—they found the experience lacked enough information about Catalina itself and ended up having to “make up” their own missions. That suggests some might expect a more informative or immersive approach and could feel shortchanged if looking for detailed local history.
Conversely, others praise the creativity and responsiveness of the guide. A reviewer mentioned, “We had so much fun figuring out clues and getting creative with our pictures and videos,” with the guide being very flexible and supportive. Smaller groups are recommended for the best experience, as one person pointed out that a larger group of 10 might be easier to split up for a smoother adventure.
The importance of a smartphone with GPS and data cannot be overstated, and the fact that the host stays connected via text or WhatsApp adds a layer of reassurance. Many reviewers appreciated the good communication and noted how the guide’s flexibility made their outing more enjoyable.
Considering the Value for Your Money
At just over $23 per person, this is a relatively affordable way to add a playful twist to your Catalina trip. The cost reflects a guided, interactive experience with the added element of a live host—a standout feature that sets this apart from more traditional self-guided walks.
However, some travelers might feel that for the price, the experience could include more detailed info about Catalina itself. If you’re hoping for a deep dive into local history or culture, this might not fully satisfy those expectations. Still, if your goal is fun, creativity, and discovering some lesser-known spots with a helpful guide, the value is solid.
Practical Tips Before You Go
- Make sure you have a fully charged smartphone with GPS and data capabilities.
- Provide your correct domestic phone number during booking to ensure smooth communication.
- Consider splitting larger groups into smaller teams for a more manageable, engaging experience.
- Bring a sense of humor and curiosity—that’s what makes these challenges worth doing.
- Since it’s family- and dog-friendly, everyone can join in, but be prepared for some walking and outdoor exploration.
- Check the weather forecast—the outdoor elements are part of the fun, and you’ll want to be comfortable.
Final Thoughts

The Catalina Crusade Scavenger Hunt offers a creative, interactive way to see Catalina Island that’s more about discovery and fun than about detailed historical insights. It’s perfect for folks who enjoy puzzles, challenges, and a bit of social interaction, especially if you’re traveling in a smaller, energetic group.
While the experience may not be every traveler’s ideal for deep learning or historical tours, it excels at providing laughs, teamwork, and a fresh perspective on Avalon’s hidden corners. The live remote host adds a personal touch that many travelers find engaging, and the flexible, outdoor-ready format makes it suitable for all kinds of weather.
If you’re curious, love a good puzzle, or just want to shake up your usual island itinerary, this scavenger hunt could be a highlight of your trip. Just keep your phone charged, your mind open, and your sense of adventure ready.
Catalina Crusade Scavenger Hunt
“We felt that $75 was too much money for what we received. There was no information about Catalina Island. We were left to "be creative" and "make u…”
FAQ
Can I participate if I don’t have a local phone number?
You’ll need to provide a correct, working domestic phone number for the remote host to contact you. If you have an international number, you can still participate by using WhatsApp or email.
How long does the scavenger hunt take?
It lasts approximately 2 hours, giving you enough time to explore without feeling rushed.
Is this experience suitable for families?
Yes, it’s family-friendly and dog-friendly, making it an inclusive activity for all ages and pets.
What should I bring?
A fully charged smartphone with GPS and data, and perhaps a bag for any extra items you want to carry along.
What if I have scheduling conflicts?
The guide has been flexible with timing issues, so reach out if needed. The key is to coordinate with your remote host beforehand.
Is there a refund if I cancel?
Yes, cancellations are free if made at least 24 hours in advance. The process is straightforward, and you get a full refund if canceled early.
If you’re after a playful, modern way to uncover Catalina’s hidden spots, the Catalina Crusade Scavenger Hunt offers a memorable, engaging twist. Perfect for small groups eager for a challenge, it combines creativity, technology, and a touch of adventure—all for an approachable price.
More Tour Reviews in Catalina Island
More Catalina Island experiences we've covered
- Private Tour of Avalon from Catalina Island
- Helicopter Transfer: Catalina Island to Long Beach
- Haunted Catalina EMF Detection Walking Tour – 12 years and older
- Amazing Avalon CA Scavenger Hunt
- Catalina Island Avalon Highlights Walking Tour
- Catalina Explorer Helicopter Tour
- Sunset Summit Catalina Island Shared Tour
- Dress up experience like a Mermaid in Avalon
- Glass Bottom Boat: Catalina Island Tour
- Avalon on Foot Self-Guided Audio Tour of Catalina Island
- Catalina Food Tour
- Private Tour Haunted Catalina Ghost
