Lunch at Iconic Redeye Grill near Central Park and Carnegie Hall!

A Practical Look at Lunching at the Iconic Redeye Grill near Carnegie Hall

If you’re wandering through Midtown Manhattan and looking to enjoy a sit-down meal that balances quality, convenience, and a touch of elegance, a lunch at Redeye Grill might just fit the bill. While I haven’t personally tried this experience, the details available paint a picture of a solid, no-fuss option to fuel your day in NYC.

What really draws attention here is the location—right across from Carnegie Hall and close to Broadway, making it perfect for a quick yet satisfying midday break. Plus, the menu offers a variety of dishes, from sushi to steaks, meaning there’s likely something for most tastes. The fact that it’s a two-course prix-fixe lunch for just $41 makes it an accessible way to enjoy a more leisurely meal without breaking the bank.

One thing to keep in mind is the limited timeframe—only 12:00 PM to 2:30 PM on weekdays—so it’s best for those on a tight schedule or with a pre-theater reservation. Also, since gratuities are included, it’s straightforward to settle up without any surprises, but alcohol and hot beverages aren’t included, which might be worth considering if you want a complete dining experience.

This experience seems well-suited for business travelers, theater-goers, or travelers seeking a classic New York lunch in a lively, central setting. If you’re someone who appreciates good food in a convenient location, and doesn’t mind sticking to the menu, Redeye Grill could be a nice addition to your NYC itinerary.

Key Points

• Prime Midtown Location: Across from Carnegie Hall and near Broadway, perfect for a quick pre-show or post-visit meal.
• Affordable, Quality Lunch: $41 for a two-course prix-fixe, including a soft drink.
• Flexible Menu: Options range from salads and seafood to burgers and vegetarian bowls.
• Convenient Timing: Open weekdays from 12:00 PM to 2:30 PM, ideal for a midday break.
• All-Inclusive Pricing: Gratuities and government fees are included, simplifying the bill.
• Limited Duration: Quick service, so it’s best suited for those on a schedule.

Exploring the Redeye Grill Experience

The location of Redeye Grill really is its strongest selling point. Situated directly across from Carnegie Hall, it’s a spot that feels both elegant and approachable. The restaurant’s American brasserie vibe offers a lively yet refined atmosphere, making it suitable whether you’re on a casual business lunch or catching a quick bite during a busy day exploring the city.

The menu offers a good variety of choices, reflecting the vibrant, diverse culinary scene of New York. For appetizers, options like the Soup of the Day, Greek Salad, Caesar Salad, Fried Calamari, and Shrimp Cocktail give you a decent mix of lighter and more substantial starters. The appetizer choices seem well-curated, with familiar favorites, and the Fried Calamari served with yuzu aioli sounds particularly appealing if you enjoy a bit of flavor complexity.

Moving onto the main courses, the selections cover different preferences. The Black Label Cheeseburger with Tillamook cheddar is a safe bet for many, especially if you’re looking for something hearty. The Grilled Teriyaki Salmon Bowl and Blackened Mahi Mahi are appealing for seafood lovers who want something flavorful but not overly complicated. Vegetarians aren’t left out either, with a Vegetarian Teriyaki Bowl featuring mushrooms, spinach, roasted peppers, and brown rice. Based on reviews and the menu, it seems like a balanced offering that caters to various dietary preferences.

The two-course structure means you get to pick one appetizer and one entrée, which is quite reasonable for the price, especially considering the location. The soft drink included keeps things simple, and the fact that gratuities are pre-included helps avoid surprises when the check arrives.

What to Expect During Your Visit

If you decide to book this experience, you can anticipate a seamless, efficient process. The meeting point at 890 7th Ave is easy to reach, especially if you’re familiar with Midtown transportation options. The tour duration of approximately 1 hour 30 minutes** is generous for a full lunch, giving you enough time to relax without feeling rushed.

Once inside, you’ll find a vibrant, lively environment—not a quiet, hushed restaurant, but one that buzzes with city energy, ideal for watching the bustling Midtown scene go by. The service is usually prompt, and the setup is designed for quick turnarounds, so expect your meal to arrive in a timely manner.

Since most travelers can participate and the experience is limited to about 10 people, it feels intimate enough for a small group, yet efficient enough to serve the needs of busy travelers or professionals. And because the lunch is weekday-only, plan accordingly if you want to include this on a weekend or evening itinerary.

The Practical Side: Value and Considerations

When you evaluate the $41 price point, it’s important to consider what’s included—the two-course meal, soft drink, gratuities, and taxes make this a straightforward deal. Compared to dining à la carte in Midtown, this offers a solid balance of convenience and quality.

However, if you’re craving something beyond the menu or want a more luxurious experience, this might feel a bit limited. It’s a good, no-fuss option if you’re on a schedule or want to avoid the tourist trap restaurants around Times Square. The lunch hours are fixed, so plan to arrive within that window to avoid missing out.

The reviews, although limited, suggest that the service is generally good and the food is satisfying—nothing overly fancy, but reliable. Since gratuities are included, you don’t need to think about tipping extra unless you want to reward particularly attentive staff.

Who is This Tour Best For?

This lunch experience is ideal for those who value location and convenience—whether you’re on a tight schedule, heading to a show, or simply want to experience a classic NYC brasserie without fuss. It’s suitable for travelers who prefer a straightforward meal with predictable quality and a lively atmosphere.

While not geared towards families or children specifically, it’s accessible for most adults and older teens interested in quick, quality food in the heart of Midtown. If you enjoy the idea of combining a city landmark (Carnegie Hall) with excellent food, this experience is worth considering.

FAQ

Is the lunch experience available on weekends?
No, this particular experience runs Monday through Friday from 12:00 PM to 2:30 PM. If you’re in town on weekends, you’ll need to look for other options.

How long does the meal take?
The average duration is about 1 hour and 30 minutes, which gives you enough time to enjoy the food and soak in the lively Midtown atmosphere.

Are drinks other than soft drinks included?
No, the package includes only soft drinks or water. Alcoholic beverages are not included and require guests to be 21+.

What is included in the price?
You get a two-course pre-fixe lunch (appetizer and entrée), a soft drink, gratuities (20%), and government fees and taxes—making it a clear, all-in-one cost.

Is this experience suitable for vegetarians?
Yes, there’s a vegetarian option available—the Vegetarian Teriyaki Bowl—so it can cater to different dietary preferences.

Can I cancel this experience?
Yes, you can cancel free of charge up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.

How do I book this experience?
You can reserve your spot through the provided booking platform, which confirms your reservation immediately.

Is this experience good for those with mobility issues?
Since the location is centrally situated in Midtown and the venue is accessible, most travelers with mobility concerns should find it manageable, but it’s always a good idea to check specific accessibility details when booking.

In the end, if you’re after a reliable, well-located, and reasonably priced lunch option near Carnegie Hall, this experience at Redeye Grill checks most boxes. It offers a chance to enjoy a taste of New York’s classic brasserie style without fuss, in a setting that feels both lively and comfortable. Perfect for a quick city break or a pre-show meal, it’s a solid pick if your plans include exploring Midtown’s cultural landmarks and needing a satisfying midday stop.