Birsay is a standout spot for travelers exploring the Orkney Islands. Its rugged coastline, historic sites like Brough of Birsay, and charming villages make it perfect for memorable guided tours. Among the options, we particularly like the Historic Orkney Coastal Charms Tour by a Native Islander for its flexible, personalized approach—ideal if you want a private experience with local insights. Meanwhile, the Neolithic Orkney Full Day Guided Tour offers a comprehensive dive into the ancient past, perfect for history lovers craving a deep, structured exploration. Both tours showcase the area’s stunning scenery and fascinating history but cater to different interests and schedules.
In this guide, you’ll find two standout options: one with a customized coastal journey led by a local, and another that covers key UNESCO sites in a day. Whether you prefer a laid-back, private outing or a full-day adventure through prehistoric sites, there’s something here to match your travel style.
1. Historic Orkney Coastal Charms Tour by a Native Islander
At number 1, this 5-hour coastal tour offers a personalized view of the Orkney Islands, led by a native islander who knows the area inside out. The tour includes scenic drives, local insights, and no strict time constraints, making it flexible and tailored to your wishes. You can start from four different locations—Kirkwall, Stromness, Orkney, or Saint Margaret’s Hope—which adds convenience for travelers arriving by ferry or cruise ship. The itinerary features hidden viewpoints (a 30-minute stop for photos), guided visits of key sites, and free time, including a dedicated Birsay guided tour lasting about an hour.
One highlight is the personalized experience, with options for private 1-on-1 tours, which many find especially engaging. The guide Calum, praised in reviews, offers a sensitive, professional approach and integrates guests’ interests seamlessly. The tour’s value lies in its flexibility—you can extend or modify the route, ensuring you see what matters most to you. At only $592 for a group of up to 4, it’s a great choice for those wanting a customized, intimate tour that balances scenic beauty with local stories.
Bottom line: This tour suits travelers who want a tailor-made experience, ample free time, and local knowledge. Perfect for small groups or individuals seeking flexibility and authenticity.
2. Neolithic Orkney Full Day Guided Tour
Number 2 on our list is the Neolithic Orkney Full Day Guided Tour, designed to fit into about 7 hours. Priced at $1,548 for groups up to 8, this tour is ideal for travelers eager to explore the prehistoric sites of the UNESCO World Heritage area with a knowledgeable guide. It takes you to Skara Brae, Europe’s best-preserved Neolithic village, allowing you to walk through ancient dwellings that date back over 5,000 years. The tour also includes a visit to the Brough of Birsay, a tidal island with ruins and stunning views, plus a guided exploration of Heart of Neolithic Orkney.
This tour is especially well-suited for cruise ship passengers or those who want a comprehensive, structured day. The guide offers detailed context about the sites, myths, and the people who built them, transforming ruins into stories. Previous reviews praise the guide’s expertise and the smooth organization, making it an easy way to cover major attractions in one day. The price reflects the depth of experience and transportation included, offering good value for those interested in history.
Bottom line: This is the choice for history geeks or families with limited time who want a deep, guided dive into Orkney’s ancient past. It’s a full, enriching day that makes the most of your visit.
How to Choose
When deciding between these tours, consider your interests, budget, and schedule. If you prefer a personalized, flexible experience that lets you explore at your own pace, the Coastal Charms Tour is hard to beat. For those with a passion for Neolithic history or arriving via cruise, the Neolithic Orkney Guided Tour offers a focused, comprehensive exploration.
Think about your travel style: do you want to customize your day and avoid large groups? Or do you prefer a structured tour packed with expert insights? Both tours require early booking, especially in peak season, and are best enjoyed with comfortable footwear and an interest in local stories or ancient ruins.
Final Thoughts
Birsay and the surrounding Orkney Islands offer an array of fantastic tour options. For a personalized coastal experience, the Heritage Charms Tour is a standout, especially for small groups and those wanting local insights. If you’re eager to absorb the prehistoric past, the Neolithic Full Day provides a thorough, guided immersion.
For different types of travelers—whether you value flexibility and local flavor or prefer structured, historical storytelling—these tours cover some of the best ways to experience Birsay and the wider Orkney Islands. Remember to book early, especially if traveling during busy months, to secure your spot. Whichever you choose, these adventures promise a memorable glimpse into one of the UK’s most captivating regions.
