Discover Edinburgh’s Dark and Sinister Past: A Walking Tour Review
If you’re drawn to the spooky, mysterious side of history, the Edinburgh’s Dark and Sinister History Walking Tour might just be your next must-do. From tales of witches and criminals to haunted cemeteries and infamous execution sites, this tour promises a chilling glimpse into the city’s darker chapters. We haven’t personally taken this tour, but based on the detailed reviews and the itinerary, it’s clear that it offers a compelling mix of storytelling, history, and atmosphere.
What caught our eye? First, the knowledgeable guides who bring the stories to life, and second, the stunning locations that make you feel like you’ve stepped into a ghost story. A potential downside? The tour runs at a gentle pace, but with almost two hours of walking and some uneven surfaces, it’s best suited for those comfortable with a moderate amount of outdoor strolling. This experience is perfect for history buffs, ghost enthusiasts, or anyone curious about Edinburgh’s darker secrets—especially those who enjoy a little spooky storytelling on their travels.
Key Points
- Engaging stories about Edinburgh’s haunted sites, witches, and notorious characters
- Guided by knowledgeable guides who make history come alive
- Accessible route through iconic and lesser-known historic streets
- Affordable price, offering good value for a 1 hour 45-minute tour of the city’s darker side
- Visuals included, with pictures to enhance storytelling
- Note on suitability: some topics may be unsuitable for young children
If you're drawn to exploring Edinburgh on foot, we've looked into these other walking experiences
An In-Depth Look at the Tour Experience
Starting Point and First Impressions
The tour kicks off at the National Museum of Scotland on Chambers Street, a central and accessible spot in Edinburgh. From there, you’ll walk to Greyfriars Kirk, renowned for its connection to the darker side of Edinburgh’s lore. Here, you’ll learn about Greyfriars Bobby, the faithful dog, and explore infamous sites like The Covenanters Prison, which is steeped in stories of religious persecution. This spot also has some Harry Potter connections, making it a fun tidbit for fans.
The guide’s storytelling begins immediately, setting a tone that’s both atmospheric and educational. As Sarah_L from her review put it, “Rob was terrific and we saw a lot of interesting things.” That’s a common theme—guides are praised for their knowledge and engaging narration, making even the somber stories memorable.
The Historic Streets and Dark Tales
Moving on, you’ll pass Grassmarket, an area once infamous for public executions. Today, it’s a lively spot, but the tales of tragedy and ghostly sightings linger. Walking through the Royal Mile, your guide points out key sites like Advocates Close, the Old Fishmarket Close, and the Castle, each with its own gruesome or mysterious story. Expect to hear about criminality, death, and tragedy—all woven into the fabric of Edinburgh’s streets.
One highlight: you’ll see prominent landmarks like John Knox House and the Flodden Wall, which add context to the city’s turbulent past. The guide will also share insights into the history of Paisley Close and the tragic events associated with it.
The Iconic Edinburgh Castle
While you won’t go inside, Edinburgh Castle looms large along the route, giving you a sense of the city’s historic weight. The guide highlights its bloody history, including tales of battles and siege. The castle acts as a backdrop for many stories, reinforcing Edinburgh’s reputation as a city filled with conflict and intrigue.
Interested in history? Here are other past-focused experiences we've examined in Edinburgh
Hidden Gems and Stories
Throughout the walk, you’ll encounter lesser-known sites and anecdotes that aren’t always in your typical guidebooks. For instance, the Cowgate—once the slum of Edinburgh—is pointed out as a gritty part of town with a dark past. The Paisley Close also holds a tragic history, adding depth to your understanding of the city’s history of hardship and violence.
The Visual Element and Interactive Aspects
A nice touch is the inclusion of pictures on a screen that bring stories to life. This visual aid helps you imagine the scenes, making the experience more immersive. Plus, at the end of the tour, you receive a souvenir map and a tour guidebook, which are great keepsakes and helpful for further exploration.
Practical Details and Overall Value
The tour lasts about 1 hour 45 minutes, covering a walkable route through Edinburgh’s Old Town. The group is limited to 10 travelers, ensuring personal attention and plenty of interaction with the guide. The cost is $23.60 per person, which we’d say is quite reasonable given the depth of stories and the guided experience.
It’s important to note that no public toilets are available along the route, and you should wear comfortable shoes, as some walking and uneven surfaces are involved. The tour is also suitable for most travelers, though some topics might be too intense or unsuitable for very young children.
Who Will Love This Tour?
If you enjoy ghost stories, historic crime tales, or darker legends, this tour is tailor-made for you. History lovers will appreciate the way stories are tied to real locations, and those interested in Edinburgh’s haunted reputation will find plenty to fascinate. It’s also a good choice for travelers who prefer guided walks that combine storytelling with sightseeing rather than museums or inside attractions.
This experience is less suited for anyone seeking a light or family-friendly activity, especially since some content could be intense for children. But if you’re comfortable with some spooky tales, you’ll find it well worth the price and duration.
Final Thoughts
The Edinburgh’s Dark and Sinister History Walking Tour offers a richly textured look into the city’s more macabre side. The knowledgeable guides, atmospheric locations, and engaging storytelling make it a worthwhile addition to any trip to Edinburgh. For just over twenty dollars, you get a chance to see some of the city’s most haunted and infamous spots with a local who truly knows how to bring the stories to life.
If you’re after a tour that balances history and mystery, and don’t mind a bit of walking, this experience is likely to leave you both entertained and enlightened. It’s especially suited for those curious about Edinburgh’s darker past and eager to explore beyond the usual tourist sights.
Edinburgh’s Dark and Sinister History Walking Tour
“It was great! Rob was terrific and we saw a lot of interesting things. Definitely got our steps in and felt like we saw a lot of the city.”
FAQ
Is this tour suitable for children?
Some topics covered are quite dark and may not be appropriate for young children. If they are comfortable with spooky stories, it could still be enjoyed, but parental discretion is advised.
How long does the tour last?
The tour is approximately 1 hour 45 minutes, covering a walk through Edinburgh’s historic streets.
What’s included in the price?
The price covers the guide, leaflets, flyers for attractions, and a souvenir map and guidebook. Entrance to attractions is not included.
Are there any physical requirements?
Yes, wear comfortable shoes and be prepared for some walking and uneven surfaces. The tour is at a gentle pace but involves outdoor walking.
Where does the tour start and end?
It begins at the National Museum of Scotland on Chambers Street and ends back at the starting point.
Can I cancel if I change my mind?
Yes, cancellations are free up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.
This tour offers a compelling peek into Edinburgh’s shadowy corners, perfect for those who love a good ghost story with their history. It’s a fun, atmospheric way to spend a couple of hours, especially if you’re intrigued by the city’s darker legends.
More Walking Tours in Edinburgh
More Tours in Edinburgh
- Edinburgh’s Landscapes Tours with a Local Guide: Private & Personalized
- Isle of Skye, Hebrides Islands and Inverness Tour from Edinburgh
- From Edinburgh: Isle of Skye & The Highlands 3-Day Tour
- Edinburgh 6hr Private Walking Tour with Certified Guide
- Loch Ness, Inverness, & Highlands 2-Day Tour from Edinburgh
- ‘Portobello’s Story’ Walking Tour with a Guide
More Tour Reviews in Edinburgh
- The Pirate’s Riddle: An Outdoor Treasure Hunt
- Edinburgh’s Landscapes Tours with a Local Guide: Private & Personalized
- Isle of Skye, Hebrides Islands and Inverness Tour from Edinburgh
- From Edinburgh: Isle of Skye & The Highlands 3-Day Tour
- Edinburgh 6hr Private Walking Tour with Certified Guide
- Loch Ness, Inverness, & Highlands 2-Day Tour from Edinburgh
More Edinburgh experiences we've covered
- The Pirate’s Riddle: An Outdoor Treasure Hunt
- Edinburgh’s Landscapes Tours with a Local Guide: Private & Personalized
- Isle of Skye, Hebrides Islands and Inverness Tour from Edinburgh
- From Edinburgh: Isle of Skye & The Highlands 3-Day Tour
- Edinburgh 6hr Private Walking Tour with Certified Guide
- Loch Ness, Inverness, & Highlands 2-Day Tour from Edinburgh
- ‘Portobello’s Story’ Walking Tour with a Guide
- From Edinburgh: Private Tour to St Andrews & East Coast Villages
- From Edinburgh: Glenkinchie Distillery & Whisky Experience
- Rosslyn Chapel and Hadrian’s Wall Small Group Day Tour
- Luxury Private Tour of The Highlands
- Private St Andrews Day Tour from Edinburgh


