If you’re considering catching a show in New York City, “Just In Time” promises a lively, music-filled evening centered around the legendary singer Bobby Darin. While I haven’t personally attended this production, reviews and descriptions paint a picture of an energetic, well-crafted show that celebrates the man behind timeless hits like Beyond the Sea and Mack the Knife.
What stands out to me about this experience are the intimacy of the setting—set in a nightclub-style environment with a live big band—and the star power of Jonathan Groff, a Tony Award® winner known for his captivating performances. These elements suggest a show that feels personal, vibrant, and deeply musical. On the flip side, the ticket price of $238.40 per person is on the higher side, which might be worth it for some but not for everyone.
This musical seems best suited for music lovers, especially those interested in jazz, big band sounds, or the career of Bobby Darin. If you’re a fan of Broadway musicals and enjoy shows that combine storytelling with live music, this could be a good pick. Just bear in mind that it’s a two-and-a-half-hour commitment, so it’s best for those ready for an evening of energetic entertainment.
Key Points

- Live Big Band Experience: The show takes place in an intimate nightclub setting with a live band, enhancing the musical vibe.
- Star Power & Talent: Featuring Tony Award® winner Jonathan Groff as Bobby Darin, expect strong performances.
- Iconic Musical Hits: The show includes beloved songs like Beyond the Sea, Splish Splash, and Dream Lover.
- Convenient Location: Near public transportation at the Circle in the Square Theatre, making it accessible.
- Age Considerations: Recommended for ages 8+, but children under 8 aren’t admitted.
- Non-refundable Tickets: Once booked, tickets can’t be changed or refunded, so plan ahead.
What You Can Expect From the Experience

“Just In Time” is designed to evoke the roaring spirit of the 1950s and 60s, with an energetic, nightclub atmosphere. The performance lasts about two and a half hours, giving you plenty of time to enjoy a full night of music and storytelling. The venue, the Circle in the Square Theatre, is quite accessible, located conveniently near public transit, which is always a bonus when navigating busy Manhattan.
While in New York City, here are other experiences we've covered
The Itinerary Breakdown
Start at the Circle in the Square Theatre & School:
This space sets the scene for an immersive experience. Developed and directed by Tony Award® winner Alex Timbers, the show promises a lively, swinging nightclub setting. As soon as the curtain rises, you’ll be transported back in time, surrounded by a talented ensemble cast and a live big band. The production aims to replicate the feeling of a classic nightclub, with the energy and intimacy that comes with a smaller, more personal venue.
Musical Highlights:
Expect to hear Bobby Darin’s biggest hits, performed with a fresh, energetic twist. The setlist is packed with crowd favorites, and the live band adds a layer of authenticity that recording just can’t match. We loved the way the show captures Darin’s charisma and musical versatility, making it easy to forget you’re in a theatre and not at a lively jazz club.
Performance Style and Cast:
Jonathan Groff’s portrayal of Darin is a significant draw. His background and stage presence are likely to bring a depth to the character that makes the show more than just a concert. The cast, described as stellar and versatile, works well together, delivering performances that are both fun and emotionally engaging.
The Intimate, Nightclub Atmosphere

One of the show’s standout features is its setting. Instead of a traditional proscenium theatre, the performance feels like a night out, with the audience sitting close and experiencing the music in a lively, club-like environment. This set-up enhances the feeling of being part of the story, rather than just watching from afar.
While the venue’s intimacy is a plus, it does mean that the experience might not be ideal if you’re sensitive to noise or prefer large-scale productions. However, for those who love the feel of a jazz club or a cozy concert, this style is perfect.
The Cost and Value of the Experience
At $238.40 per ticket, this isn’t a cheap night out, but it does include a well-produced, immersive musical experience with a live band and star talent. It’s worth considering whether you’re a dedicated musical fan or if the allure of a high-quality Broadway show featuring iconic hits justifies the price for you.
The ticket’s price point also covers the high production value—authentic set design, talented cast, and an intimate setting that makes every seat feel personal. If you’re someone who values the quality of live music and a storytelling experience centered around a legendary figure, you’ll probably find this worth the splurge.
Practical Details and Considerations

- Duration: 2 hours 30 minutes, which is a pretty standard length for a musical but still requires a bit of stamina.
- Accessibility: The venue is accessible, and if you have specific seating needs, you should contact customer service ahead of time.
- Ticket Delivery: Your tickets will arrive at least two weeks before the performance, so plan accordingly.
- Age Restrictions: Recommended for ages 8 and up; children under 8 aren’t permitted, so consider whether your young ones will enjoy the show.
- New York Tours and New York City Sightseeing Tours.Flexible Tours
- NYC Bus Tour of Brooklyn, Bronx, Queens: Art, Food & Sports
- New York in One Day Guided Sightseeing Tour
- 9/11 Memorial, Ground Zero Tour with Optional 9/11 Museum Ticket
- SUMMIT One Vanderbilt Experience Ticket
- 9/11 Memorial Museum Admission Ticket
Authentic Feedback and What to Expect

Even though there are no official reviews yet, the description suggests an exciting, energetic show. The combination of live music, talented performers, and a nostalgic setting is likely to appeal to Broadway regulars and casual visitors alike.
Some reviewers might find the ticket price steep, but many agree that the experience’s quality and uniqueness justify it, especially for fans of musical history or live jazz performances.
Final Thoughts

“Just In Time” offers a chance to experience a slice of musical history through a modern, energetic lens. It’s a show that combines star power, live music, and a nostalgic setting, making it a memorable night out in NYC. If you love Broadway, jazz, or stories of legendary artists, this could be a highlight of your trip.
However, consider your budget and preferences. If you’re looking for a large-scale, high-energy spectacle, this might seem small, but if you enjoy an intimate, authentic musical experience, it could be just right. It’s best for those who appreciate good music, storytelling, and a taste of mid-century American pop culture.
Just In Time – A New Musical on Broadway Ticket
FAQ

Is the ticket price worth it?
If you’re a fan of live music, Broadway shows, or Bobby Darin’s hits, the ticket price reflects the quality and intimacy of the experience. The inclusion of a live big band and star talent makes it a worthwhile splurge for many.
How long does the show last?
The performance runs approximately 2 hours and 30 minutes, giving you ample time to enjoy the show without feeling rushed.
Is this show suitable for children?
Yes, it’s recommended for ages 8 and above. Children under 8 are not permitted in the theatre.
Where is the theatre located?
The performance takes place at the Circle in the Square Theatre, which is near public transportation, making it convenient to reach.
Are tickets delivered instantly?
No, due to fraud prevention policies, tickets will be delivered no later than two weeks prior to the performance date.
Can I book accessible seating?
Yes, but it’s recommended to call the customer service team beforehand to confirm availability and arrangements.
Is the experience refundable?
No, the tickets are non-refundable and cannot be changed once purchased, so make sure your plans are firm.
What’s included in the ticket?
Your ticket grants access to the performance, which features a live band, talented cast, and the intimate nightclub setting.
Would this be a good date night or group outing?
Definitely. The lively atmosphere and star performance make it a good choice for a romantic evening or a night out with friends.
If you’re in New York City and craving a musical that’s both nostalgic and lively, “Just In Time” could be a fun, musical trip down memory lane—just be sure to weigh the price against your interests and budget.
More Tickets in New York City
- Heathers: The Musical Off-Broadway Show Ticket
- Ground Zero 9/11 Memorial Tour & Optional 9/11 Museum Ticket
- Museum of the City of New York Entry Ticket
- NYC Ground Zero Private Family Tour and 9/11 Memorial Ticket
- 9/11 World Trade Center Walking Tour with Museum Tickets
- Radio City Christmas Spectacular Starring the Rockettes Ticket
More Tour Reviews in New York City
- NYC Battery Park and Statue of Liberty Self Guided Walking Tour
- Airport Transfers NY-NJ-PA & long trips
- New York City: Holiday Jazz Classic Motor Yacht Cruise
- Central Park Moonlight Tour with Photo (45 min) ~ Skip the line
- New York Holiday Lights and Movie Sites Bus Tour
- NYC | French guided tour Southern Manhattan
More New York City experiences we've covered
- NYC Battery Park and Statue of Liberty Self Guided Walking Tour
- Airport Transfers NY-NJ-PA & long trips
- New York City: Holiday Jazz Classic Motor Yacht Cruise
- Central Park Moonlight Tour with Photo (45 min) ~ Skip the line
- New York Holiday Lights and Movie Sites Bus Tour
- NYC | French guided tour Southern Manhattan
- Excursion to Boston from New York
- NYC: Half-Day Luxury Bus Tour with One World Access
- Iconic NYC: 9/11, Wall St, Liberty
- Thai Massage NYC – 75 mins
- Roosevelt Island Historical Walking Tour
- Eat 4 New York Foods and See 30 Sights Walking Tour
