Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish

If you’re thinking about adding a fishing adventure to your Key West trip, you’ve probably come across options that promise big thrills and even bigger fish. This particular tour, offered by Corsair 2 Sportfishing, has earned a perfect 5.0-star rating from over 100 reviews, and it’s clear why. It’s a private, well-equipped sportfishing trip designed for up to six anglers, promising a solid chance to reel in some impressive catches like mahi mahi and tuna.

What really stands out about this experience is the quality of the boat and crew. Many reviewers mention the professionalism and friendliness of Captain Jeff and his team, which definitely helps if you’re new to deep-sea fishing or if you’re bringing along family or friends. Plus, the boat’s amenities—air conditioning, private bathrooms, a kitchen, and beds—make the trip comfortable, even for those who might get a little seasick or just want to relax in between bites.

That said, one thing to keep in mind is the price — at $950 for a group of up to six, it’s not exactly cheap. It’s an investment, but one that many find worthwhile given the quality of the experience and the chance to catch some sizable fish. If you’re eager to spend a half or full day on the water with knowledgeable guides, this one might be just right.

This tour is especially well-suited for friends or couples who want a private adventure, seasoned anglers eager for offshore action, or families with older kids who can handle a bit of time on the water. It’s also ideal if you value comfort and top-notch equipment alongside the fishing experience itself.

Key Points

• Private, exclusive experience with up to six participants ensures personalized attention.
• Well-equipped boat with modern electronics, amenities, and safety gear boosts confidence and comfort.
• Flexible trip durations allow you to choose between half, 3/4, or full-day outings depending on your schedule.
• Catch a variety of fish like mahi mahi, tuna, wahoo, sailfish, and marlin, making it a rewarding trip.
• High safety standards and good reviews indicate trustworthy operation.
• Weather-dependent cancellations are free up to 24 hours in advance, making planning a bit easier.

What to Expect on the Water

This trip takes you up to 18 miles offshore — a good distance for serious fishing without straying too far from the beautiful coast of Key West. The boat, called Corsair 2, is a sportfisher with all the gear you need. Think outriggers, a fighting chair, live bait tanks, ice boxes, and advanced navigation systems. These features aren’t just for show; they’re designed to maximize your chances of hooking some big fish.

You’ll start your day at the meeting point at 5950 Peninsular Ave. After a safety briefing and a bit of orientation, you’ll head out into the deep blue waters. If you’re lucky, you’ll land mahi mahi, which many reviewers describe as thrilling, or a wahoo and tuna, which are equally sought after. Some reviews mention catching multiple fish at once, with one visitor noting, “We hooked four fish at the same time!” The crew works hard to help you get bites, whether you’re an experienced angler or just giving it a try.

You also get bottled water included, which is handy on a hot day. Alcohol isn’t included, so if you want drinks, you’ll need to bring your own or purchase them locally. The trip duration can range from around four hours to a full day, depending on your booking choice. Longer trips are great if you want more time to sit back, fish, and enjoy the scenery.

Comfort and Convenience

One of the big selling points here is the boat itself. Unlike some fishing charters that are more basic, Corsair 2 Sportfishing offers a comfortable environment. The boat has air conditioning, which is a blessing if the weather turns hot, as well as two private restrooms, making the experience more pleasant—especially for longer trips. There’s even a small kitchen onboard, so you can grab snacks or drinks without having to leave the boat.

Several reviewers commented on the crew’s professionalism and friendliness, which adds a lot to the overall experience. Christian and Jeff, in particular, are praised for their personable nature and willingness to work hard to help guests catch fish. One review summed it up perfectly: “They worked very hard to give us the opportunity to catch some fish, and I ended up catching a large mahi to my delight!”

The Experience of Fishing in Key West

Deep sea fishing in Key West is about more than just catching fish. It’s about being out on the water, enjoying the views, and feeling that thrill when you finally hook something big. The scenery is stunning, with miles of open water, and the boat’s flybridge gives you a great vantage point for spotting activity or just soaking in the surroundings.

While catching fish isn’t guaranteed — as one reviewer pointed out, “we didn’t catch anything on our four-hour trip” — the crew’s efforts and the boat’s capabilities give you the best shot. Several reviews say the crew is attentive and responsive, constantly adjusting tactics if the fish aren’t biting right away. One even mentioned that the captain is very knowledgeable about what’s biting and where, which can make or break your trip.

Price and Value

At $950 for a private group up to six, this trip isn’t exactly a bargain. But when you compare it to other private charters with similar amenities and success stories, it’s often seen as good value. You’re paying not just for the chance to catch fish but for the comfort, safety, and personalized service. Many reviews highlight catching multiple fish early in the day and the crew’s efforts to maximize your experience.

It’s worth noting that most people book about two months in advance — so planning ahead is wise if you want to secure your preferred date. The options for half, 3/4, or full-day trips give you flexibility depending on your schedule and how much fishing you want to do.

Who Should Book This Tour?

This trip is perfect for those who want a private, comfortable, and well-organized fishing experience. It’s great for couples, families with older children, small groups of friends, or seasoned anglers looking to add a memorable catch to their trip. If you’re seeking a more casual, less guided experience, or if you’re on a tight budget, this might not be the best fit. But if you value professionalism, amenities, and a good shot at landing sizeable fish, this tour checks all the boxes.

Final Thoughts

For anyone wanting a solid deep-sea fishing adventure in Key West, this tour from Corsair 2 Sportfishing offers a lot. The boat’s comfort features, modern equipment, and attentive crew create a welcoming environment, while the chance to reel in mahi mahi, tuna, or even marlin keeps the excitement high. It’s clear from reviews that many guests leave with stories about catching their biggest fish ever, making it a trip worth considering if fishing is your main goal.

Certainly, it’s an investment, but many reviewers agree it’s worth the price for the quality and personalized experience. Keep in mind the weather, as trips are weather-dependent, and being flexible about cancellations can save you some headache.

This is a tour that balances adventure with comfort, making it a solid pick for anyone serious about fishing or simply wanting a memorable day on the water.

FAQs

Is this a private tour?
Yes, it’s a private experience, meaning only your group will participate, offering a more personalized and relaxed environment.

What is included in the price?
The cost covers the boat, fishing gear, safety equipment, bottled water, and a crew dedicated to helping you catch fish. The boat also features amenities like restrooms, a kitchen, and air conditioning.

Can I choose the trip duration?
Yes, you can select between half-, 3/4-, or full-day trips depending on your preferences and schedule.

What fish can I expect to catch?
Common catches include mahi mahi, wahoo, tuna, sailfish, marlin, snapper, and grouper, among others.

Is there any food or drinks included?
Bottled water is provided. Alcoholic beverages aren’t included, so bring your own if desired.

What happens if the weather is bad?
Trips are weather-dependent. If canceled due to poor weather, you’ll be offered a different date or a full refund if you prefer.

Is there a maximum weight or age limit?
Most travelers can participate, and service animals are allowed. For specific age restrictions, it’s best to check directly with the provider.

How far offshore do we go?
Up to 18 miles offshore, which is a good distance for serious fishing without going too far into open water.

How far in advance should I book?
Most people book around 55 days in advance, so it’s wise to plan and reserve early to secure your preferred date.

If you’re after a reliable, comfortable, and successful fishing trip in Key West, this tour offers a strong combination of quality boat, expert crew, and the chance to land impressive fish. It’s a trip that many guests find memorable — perfect for anglers or anyone who just loves being out on the water chasing the big catch.