NYC: Five Star Dining. All-Star Dueling Pianos.

If you’re looking for a night that combines great food, lively music, and a good dose of entertainment, this NYC Five Star Dining. All-Star Dueling Pianos experience might catch your eye. While I haven’t personally joined this event, reviews and details paint a pretty appealing picture. It’s billed as the longest-running dueling pianos show in NYC history, set within an exclusive, underground space at a top-tier steak and seafood restaurant.

What really stands out are the interactive song requests—with thousands of options—that promise a different show every time. Plus, the venue itself sounds pretty special, tucked away inside the Hunt and Fish Club near Times Square, providing a mix of elegance and intimacy.

One thing to consider is the $40 minimum spend on food and drinks, which can be a surprise if you’re not prepared for it. Also, this experience is best suited for those aged 16 and older, so families with young kids might want to look elsewhere. But if you’re after a fun, energetic night that combines live music, great food, and a lively crowd, this could be just the ticket.

This experience is ideal for couples, groups of friends, or anyone wanting to enjoy NYC’s nightlife with a twist. If you’re into interactive shows, good food, and a vibrant atmosphere, keep reading for all the details.

Key Points

• Unique Venue: An underground showroom inside a renowned NYC steakhouse, offering an exclusive feel.
• Interactive Entertainment: Sing along to thousands of songs, with no two shows being exactly the same.
• Quality Food & Drinks: Crafted cocktails, designer burgers, and a restaurant famous for its bread.
• Flexible Booking: Reserve now, pay later, with free cancellation up to 24 hours in advance.
• Price & Value: $59 per person, including the show; expect a $40 minimum spend on food and beverages.
• Family Friendly: Not suitable for children under 16, making it more of an adult night out.

You can check availability for your dates here:

An In-Depth Look at the Experience

The Venue and Atmosphere

The charm of this experience starts with its location inside the Hunt and Fish Club, a well-known NYC steak and seafood restaurant. The fact that it’s an underground, secret showroom adds a sense of exclusivity—think of it as discovering a hidden gem in Times Square. This sets the scene for an evening away from the typical tourist hustle, with a more intimate, club-like ambiance.

Guests check in at the host stand and are seated at tables reserved for their arrival. The venue tends to be cozy but lively, filled with the buzz of anticipation. The setting is elegant yet comfortable, perfect for sitting back with a cocktail and relaxing before the show kicks off.

The Show Itself: Dueling Pianos

The core of this experience is, of course, the dueling pianos. The show is renowned as the best in the USA, thanks to its energetic, interactive nature. The performers are seasoned entertainers who encourage sing-alongs, laughter, and fun throughout the night. With thousands of songs available, there’s always a chance to request your favorite tune—be it classic rock, pop, or even some unexpected surprises.

Multiple reviews praise the dynamic nature of the performance, emphasizing that “no two shows are alike”. This makes repeat visits appealing, as you can come back and still discover new moments.

Food & Beverage: A Highlight

While the focus is on the entertainment, the restaurant’s menu adds a lot to the experience. The Hunt and Fish Club is famous for its designer burgers, craft cocktails, and, of course, bread—which many reviews mention as a must-try. The $40 minimum spend on food and drinks isn’t just a formality but a chance to indulge in high-quality fare in a fun environment.

Popular choices include signature cocktails and well-crafted dishes that elevate the evening from just a show to a full dining experience. Keep in mind that additional gratuity is customary for the performers, so plan your budget accordingly.

More Great Tours Nearby

Timing and Duration

The event runs about 4 hours, with seating at 7 p.m. and the show starting around 8:30 p.m. This timing maximizes your dining experience, allowing you to enjoy your meal before the musical entertainment begins. It’s a good option for a relaxed night out rather than a hurried quick event.

Cost and Value

At $59 per person, this experience is quite competitive for what it offers—live entertainment, reserved seating, and a high-quality meal. However, the $40 minimum on food and beverages can push the total cost if you don’t come prepared to indulge. That said, reviews suggest that most guests find the quality of food and drinks worth it, especially since the venue is known for its exquisite menu.

The ticket price covers the entire show, which means you’re paying primarily for the entertainment and reserved seating. If you enjoy interactive performances and a vibrant atmosphere, many feel it’s a good value.

What You Can Expect from the Night

The Check-In and Seating

Upon arrival, you’ll check in at the host stand and be directed to your reserved table. Seating is arranged to foster a lively, communal atmosphere, so don’t expect to be tucked away in a corner unless you specifically request it. The venue ensures every guest has a good view of the stage, and the tables are ideal for enjoying both dinner and the show.

The Show Dynamics

Once the performers start, you’ll quickly notice their high energy and rapport with the audience. They invite song requests, encourage sing-alongs, and even joke around—making it clear that this isn’t your typical static musical performance.

Guests frequently mention the interactive nature: “The performers are engaging and approachable, making everyone feel part of the fun.” The diversity of songs is a plus, ensuring that everyone gets a chance to hear their favorites.

Food & Drinks

The menu at Hunt and Fish Club is a highlight, with craft cocktails and signature burgers that most reviews praise. The bread alone is famously delicious. While the menu isn’t detailed in the data, the overall impression is that dining here adds a luxurious touch to the lively evening.

The Experience: Fun, Laughter, and Singing

Expect a party atmosphere—it’s not a sit-back-and-be-serious kind of show. The performers are skilled at keeping the energy high and getting guests involved. Some reviews note that the show is lively and playful, making it perfect for those looking to celebrate or simply have a good laugh.

Potential Drawbacks

The main consideration is the $40 minimum spend, which might be unexpected for some. If you’re not a big eater or drinker, this could feel like a lot. Also, it’s not suitable for children under 16, so families with young kids will need to look elsewhere.

Another point to keep in mind is that the event is a paid, ticketed experience, and only 50 tickets are available for each night, so advance booking is highly recommended.

Who Should Consider This Experience?

If you’re a fan of interactive, lively entertainment combined with good food and drinks, this experience is a solid choice. It’s particularly well-suited for couples or groups of friends looking for a memorable night in NYC. Music lovers who enjoy sing-alongs and a convivial atmosphere will find plenty to love here.

However, if you prefer a quiet, romantic dinner or are traveling with young children, this event might not be the best fit. It’s adult-oriented, energetic, and designed for those who want to get involved and have fun.

Final Thoughts

This NYC dueling pianos experience offers a unique blend of live, interactive music and upscale dining within a secret, exclusive setting. The combination of entertainment, quality food, and a lively crowd makes it ideal for anyone wanting a fun, energetic night out. While the $40 minimum spend could be a surprise, many feel the quality of the food and the overall atmosphere make it worthwhile.

If you’re craving a night of sing-alongs, laughter, and good drinks in a stylish, intimate venue, this could be just what you need. It’s perfect for celebrating something special, or simply enjoying the vibrant NYC nightlife with friends.

FAQs

Is this experience suitable for children?
No, it’s not suitable for children under 16 years old, mainly because of the adult-oriented entertainment and atmosphere.

How long does the event last?
The entire experience runs about 4 hours, with seating at 7 p.m. and the show starting around 8:30 p.m.

What’s included in the ticket price?
Your ticket covers the dueling pianos show, reserved table seating, and the opportunity to request songs. Food and drinks are not included but are available for the required minimum spend.

Do I need to pay extra for song requests?
Yes, song requests are encouraged and typically involve a gratuity for the performers, in addition to your food and beverage minimum.

How far in advance should I book?
Tickets are limited, with only 50 available per night, so booking early is recommended to secure your spot.

What should I bring?
Bring a credit card, cash, and your ID to check in. Arrive a little early to settle in and enjoy the atmosphere.

Is there a dress code?
While not explicitly stated, the venue’s upscale reputation suggests smart casual attire is appropriate.

Whether you’re after a fun night of singing, craving a delicious meal, or both, this experience ticks a lot of boxes. It’s a lively, memorable way to spend an evening in New York, especially if you love interactive shows and a touch of exclusivity.

You can check availability for your dates here: