St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl

If you’re someone who loves a mix of history, storytelling, and a relaxed night out with a bit of an edge, the St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl might just be your cup of tea—or your glass of beer. We’ve come across this tour and wanted to share a detailed look, so you can decide if it’s a fit for your trip. It’s a chance to uncover some of the city’s darker tales while hopping between cozy local bars.

What immediately draws us in about this experience? First, the knowledgeable guides who spin chilling tales with ease, making history come alive. Second, the stunning visuals of St. Augustine’s historic streets and art district, which add atmosphere and context to the stories. On the flip side, a quick heads-up: this is very much a drinks-focused tour, so if you’re not keen on alcohol, it might not be your ideal way to explore history.

This tour is perfect for those who enjoy storytelling mixed with a laid-back pub vibe. Whether you’re a history buff, a fan of true crime, or simply looking for a different way to see the city at night, it offers something memorable. It’s not necessarily a family-friendly option, but for adult travelers who want a mix of entertainment and education, it can be a great choice.

Key Points

• Engaging storytelling by passionate guides who bring true crime stories to life.
• Visit historic pubs like Forgotten Tonic and Casa Reina, blending local drink culture with dark tales.
• Uncover secrets behind crimes like serial murders, unsolved cases, and infamous local figures.
• Includes the historic art district and central downtown areas, offering a well-rounded experience.
• Relatively affordable at $35 per person for 2 hours, with plenty of stories packed into a short evening.
• Small group setting (max 9 participants) for a more intimate, personalized experience.

You can check availability for your dates here:

The Experience: What Exactly Happens During the Tour?

The tour kicks off at Pizalley’s Chianti Room, where you’ll meet your guide and settle in with a drink. This arrival point is a good starting spot—cozy, relaxed, and perfect for setting the tone. Here, your guide begins weaving in stories of William Darrell Lindsey, a serial killer who targeted addicts and sex workers between 1983 and 1996. The local flavor of crime makes the stories more compelling, especially with a drink in hand.

Moving on, you’ll visit Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, where the narrative shifts to the murder of Father Rene Robert, who was known for his work aiding ex-convicts. It’s a stark contrast—stories of kindness turned tragic—adding depth to the tour’s storytelling.

Next stop is Forgotten Tonic, on the oldest street in the U.S., Aviles Street. Here, you’ll learn about a murder that took place on March 2, 1800, which offers a glimpse into early American life and violence. The history in this part of town is palpable, with cobblestone streets and historic charm making the stories even more vivid.

As the tour progresses into Saint George Street and Cathedral Place, the stories become more varied. You’ll hear about the unsolved murder of Lieutenant Guillermo Delaney and the strange case of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley, a model, Broadway performer, and TV hostess who was murdered. These stories aren’t just grisly—they’re told with enough detail to make you think about the people behind the crimes.

Finally, the group heads to Prohibition Kitchen, a vintage gastropub with a great vibe. Here, you can unwind with another drink and reflect on what you’ve heard. The stop wraps up the evening, leaving you with plenty to think about and a new appreciation for St. Augustine’s less explored stories.

The Value of the Tour

For just $35, the experience offers a rich blend of history, local culture, and entertainment. The small group size ensures you get attention from your guide and can ask questions. Reviews praise the knowledgeable guides—one reviewer called Rob “the man,” highlighting how much energy he puts into the storytelling. This personal touch makes the tour feel more like an evening with a friend than a scripted presentation.

Some travelers found the focus on drinking a bit unexpected. One reviewer mentioned that most of the tour involved sitting in bars and drinking alone—so if you’re hoping for more walking and less bar-hopping, keep that in mind. Also, since St. Augustine doesn’t have a ton of true crime, some stories are less sensational and more about local legends and historical murders.

The overall feedback is positive—many mention the relaxed vibe, insightful stories, and the stunning views of the city’s historic streets. It’s a tour that appeals to those wanting a different look at St. Augustine’s past, especially in the evening when the city’s ambiance truly comes alive.

Practical Tips for Your Visit

• Bring your passport or ID and driver’s license since they’re required for checking in.
• The tour is rain or shine, so dress accordingly—comfortable shoes are a good idea since you’ll walk approximately 0.9 miles.
• The end location varies, but it’s typically in the downtown area, making it easy to find your way afterward.
• Since the tour is limited to 9 participants, booking in advance is recommended, especially during peak seasons.
• Remember, food and drinks are not included, so plan to purchase additional beverages along the way.
• This tour is only suitable for those 21 and over.

Who Should Consider This Tour?

This experience is best suited for adults interested in history, true crime stories, or local legends. It’s ideal for travelers who enjoy a casual, social atmosphere and are comfortable with the focus on alcohol consumption. If you’re looking for a quiet evening or a family-friendly activity, this probably isn’t the right fit.

It’s also perfect if you want to combine your love of storytelling with a fun night out—especially if you enjoy exploring city streets at night and hearing about the less glamorous, more haunting side of history.

More Great Tours Nearby

Our Final Take

The St. Augustine True Crime Pub Crawl offers a unique way to experience the city’s past, blending engaging storytelling with the cozy atmosphere of local pubs. It’s a fun and affordable activity that gives you insight into the darker chapters of St. Augustine’s history, all served up with a good dose of local charm. The small group setting and passionate guides make it a memorable experience—one that’s particularly well-suited for curious travelers who love a good story and a relaxed evening.

While it’s not a tour for those looking for a comprehensive historical overview or a family-friendly outing, it’s an enjoyable way to spend an evening with friends or fellow travelers. Just remember it’s about the stories, the drinks, and the atmosphere—so come with an open mind and a sense of adventure.

FAQ

Is this tour suitable for children?
No, the tour is only for those 21 and over due to the alcohol-focused setting.

How long does the tour last?
It runs for about 2 hours, usually in the evening.

Do I need to prepare anything before the tour?
Just bring a valid ID or driver’s license. No special prep is necessary.

Are drinks included in the price?
No, drinks are not included; you purchase beverages at each stop.

What’s the meeting point?
You’ll meet your guide at the Ghost City Tours store, located at 32 Charlotte St.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, free cancellation is available up to 24 hours in advance.

Is it easy to find my way after the tour?
Yes, the ending location varies but is in the downtown area, making it easy to explore the city afterward.

How many people are in the group?
The tour is limited to 9 participants for a more intimate experience.

If you enjoy stories about local legends, enjoy a relaxed pub atmosphere, and want to learn about some of St. Augustine’s darker moments, this tour could be a great addition to your trip. Just be ready for an evening of chilling tales, good drinks, and a chance to see the city from a different perspective.

You can check availability for your dates here: