If you’re a fan of the hit series or just love immersive theater, you’ll find this Broadway production quite intriguing. While we haven’t personally caught the show, reviews highlight it as a “jaw-dropping, must-see theatrical marvel” with stunning visuals and a compelling story rooted in the Stranger Things universe. It’s a chance to step into the fictional world of Hawkins, Indiana, in 1959, and explore the origins of the monster-filled town we all know and love.
Two things that really stand out are the spectacular staging—critics say, “How the hell did they do this?”—and the way it deepens the show’s mythology, giving fans more context to the story. On the flip side, a consideration is that the play’s content is tied closely to the TV series’ dark themes, so it might not be suitable for everyone, especially under 16 without an adult. This experience feels tailored for those who enjoy a mix of suspense, nostalgia, and theatrical spectacle, particularly if you’re comfortable with the show’s darker aspects.
One potential drawback? The ticket price of $97.76 per person might seem a bit steep for some, especially when you factor in the non-refundable policy. Still, given the production’s praised visual effects and the uniqueness of a Broadway show based on a beloved series, many would say it’s a worthwhile splurge. If you’re a “Stranger Things” fan or crave a night of cutting-edge theater in NYC, this could be a highlight of your trip.
Key Points

- Location & Accessibility: Held at the iconic Marquis Theatre, well-connected by public transportation.
- Duration & Content: Approximately 2 hours 45 minutes, suitable for ages 12+; under 16 must be accompanied by an adult.
- Pricing & Value: At about $97, it’s on the pricier side but justifiable given the production quality.
- Experience Type: A theatrical adventure rooted in the series’ mythology, with intense suspense and stunning visual effects.
- Booking & Policies: Most tickets are booked about 42 days in advance; non-refundable, so plan accordingly.
- Ideal for: Fans of the series, theater enthusiasts, and those interested in a dark, suspenseful story set in the 1950s.
Exploring the Itinerary & Experience

While in New York City, here are other experiences we've covered
Stop 1: Marquis Theatre – The Heart of the Action
The show kicks off at the historic Marquis Theatre, a venue known for hosting Broadway’s most captivating productions. Set in 1959 Hawkins, the story centers around the Creel family. The young Henry, eager to escape his troubled past, makes a pivotal connection with Patty, a fellow outsider. This relationship is a core part of the narrative, giving the play emotional depth amidst the suspense.
Critics highlight that the play is set within the world and mythology of Stranger Things, so fans will appreciate the rich backstory that the production weaves into the performance. It’s not just a retelling; it’s a fresh look at Hawkins’ origins, blending historical elements with the show’s supernatural themes. Expect intense moments as the town faces a series of shocking crimes, and Henry’s internal struggle becomes more apparent.
The Visuals and Atmosphere
While watching the show, you’ll notice the stunning spectacle—the set design, lighting, and effects seem to push the boundaries of theatrical magic. Patrons have been heard asking, “How did they do this?” and that’s a good sign of the high-quality production values. The visuals evoke the eeriness and tension that fans love, making each scene feel immersive and real.
Content & Audience Suitability
The play is recommended for ages 12 and up. It’s important to note that children under 16 must be accompanied by an adult, given the intensity of the themes. The director and cast maintain a balance between suspense and storytelling, but the dark content might be unsettling for sensitive viewers. Check your comfort level with the series’ themes before booking.
The Broadway Experience – More Than Just a Show

After the play, you’ll enjoy the authentic Broadway atmosphere. The area is vibrant, filled with theaters showcasing all kinds of world-class productions. While admission to the Broadway walk is free, you’ll get to soak in the city’s lively theater district, which is worth a visit on its own.
- New York Tours and New York City Sightseeing Tours.Flexible Tours
- 3 Hour NYC Private Limousine Tour
- NYC Bus Tour of Brooklyn, Bronx, Queens: Art, Food & Sports
- New York in One Day Guided Sightseeing Tour
- 9/11 Memorial, Ground Zero Tour with Optional 9/11 Museum Ticket
- SUMMIT One Vanderbilt Experience Ticket
Ticketing & Logistics
Your tickets will be assigned the best available seats at the time of purchase, and your actual tickets will be delivered no later than two weeks before the show. This setup helps avoid last-minute surprises but also means you should plan ahead. The ticket price of about $97.76 reflects the high-quality production, but for many, it’s an investment in a memorable night out.
Accessibility & Policies
Accessible seating is available—just give the provider a call beforehand. Remember, you’ll need to bring valid ID if you’re 18 or older, and the experience is non-refundable, so double-check your plans before purchasing.
Why This Tour Might Be Worth It

If you’re a dedicated Stranger Things fan eager to explore the series’ history or crave the thrill of a meticulously crafted theatrical spectacle, this show offers something quite special. It combines nostalgia with suspense, set against the timeless allure of Broadway’s grand stage.
Likewise, those who enjoy visual effects and storytelling will find themselves captivated. The setting in 1959 Hawkins adds an intriguing historical layer, giving more depth to the show’s universe. Plus, the 2 hours 45 minutes duration includes enough time to fully learn about the story without it feeling rushed.
Real-World Considerations
While the price is justified for many, keep in mind the non-refundable policy and the fact that tickets are often booked well in advance—42 days being the average. If your schedule is flexible, you may find good availability, but last-minute plans might be tricky. Also, the play’s dark themes mean it’s not suitable for very young children, so plan accordingly.
Final Thoughts

This Broadway show is a unique way to experience the world of Stranger Things beyond the screen. The production promises spectacular visuals and an engaging story rooted in the series’ mythology, making it a memorable outing for fans and theater lovers alike. The setting in 1959 Hawkins offers a fresh perspective, adding historical intrigue that enhances the overall experience.
While the ticket cost might seem steep, many will find value in the visual spectacle and immersive storytelling. It’s best suited for those comfortable with the show’s darker themes and who are eager for a theatrical adventure with a nostalgic twist. If you love a good suspenseful story set in a richly imagined universe, this show could very well be a highlight of your New York City trip.
Stranger Things: The First Shadow on Broadway Ticket
FAQ

Is this experience suitable for children?
It’s recommended for ages 12 and up. Children under 16 need to be accompanied by an adult due to the content’s nature.
How long is the show?
The performance lasts approximately 2 hours and 45 minutes, including breaks or scene changes.
Where is the show held?
At the Marquis Theatre, a well-known Broadway venue in NYC.
How far in advance should I book?
Most tickets are booked about 42 days ahead, so planning early is advisable to secure preferred dates.
Are tickets refundable?
No, this experience is non-refundable and cannot be changed once booked.
Will I get my tickets in time?
Yes, tickets will be delivered no later than two weeks prior to the performance.
Is there accessible seating?
Yes, accessible seats are available—just call the provider before booking.
What if I’m traveling with a group?
Seats are assigned at the time of purchase; large groups should contact customer service in advance for arrangements.
Do I need to show ID?
Guests aged 18 or older need a valid government-issued photo ID; minors can show school ID, birth certificate, or social security card.
Can I buy tickets on the day of the show?
It’s best to book in advance, as most tickets are reserved weeks ahead; same-day availability may be limited.
If you’re into theater, the series, or both, this show offers a compelling night out. Just remember to check the content, book early, and prepare for a visually stunning experience that might just make you ask, “How did they do this?”
More Tickets in New York City
- Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club on Broadway Ticket
- NYC Statue of Liberty Ellis Island Visit with Ferry Ticket
- NYC: 9/11 Memorial Tour and Optional Observatory Ticket
- New York City: Museum of Broadway Entry Ticket
- Statue of Liberty Ellis Island Cruise with One World Trade Ticket
- NYC: Drunk Shakespeare Ticket – Live Theatre and Cocktails
More Tour Reviews in New York City
- Central Park Pedicab Tour with local Guide
- NYC: Aladdin the Musical on Broadway
- Central Park Pedicab Guided Tours with Theater
- New York Wine Tasting Private Tour with Wine Expert
- Departure from Manhattan to John F Kennedy Airport JFK by Sedan
- Niagara Falls Tour from NYC | Optional Maid of the Mist Boat Ride
More New York City experiences we've covered
- Central Park Pedicab Tour with local Guide
- NYC: Aladdin the Musical on Broadway
- Central Park Pedicab Guided Tours with Theater
- New York Wine Tasting Private Tour with Wine Expert
- Departure from Manhattan to John F Kennedy Airport JFK by Sedan
- Niagara Falls Tour from NYC | Optional Maid of the Mist Boat Ride
- SUMMIT One Vanderbilt Skip-the-Line Premium Experience with Tour
- Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club on Broadway Ticket
- NYC: Central Park Bike Rental
- Reel NYC: Walking Tour with Pedro
- NYC : Big Apple City Lights & Broadway Express Tour 40 Mins
- See 30 Top New York Sights (Walking Tour) & Go Up The Empire State Building!
