New York City’s Best Pizza tour

If you’re heading to New York City and love pizza (who doesn’t?), a guided tasting tour through Greenwich Village might just be your perfect afternoon. We’ve read plenty of reviews and details about this New York City’s Best Pizza Tour, and honestly, it seems like a solid way to explore local favorites while satisfying your cravings. It’s a small-group experience, capped at 14 people, which means you’re likely to get a more personal, relaxed vibe rather than feeling like just another number.

What we especially appreciate is that this tour offers a good mix of authentic bites and insider stories — perfect if you’re into understanding NYC’s culinary roots or just want to sample a range of pizza styles without wandering aimlessly. Plus, the price point of $59 per person is quite reasonable considering you’ll be tasting up to five different pizzerias.

However, a possible consideration is that the tour is quite focused on pizza — so if you’re after a broader food experience or want to explore other cuisines, this might feel a bit niche. Also, keep in mind that it’s a walking tour, so if you have mobility issues or just want a quick sit-down meal, this might not be ideal. But if you’re a pizza lover eager to explore Greenwich Village’s hidden gems, this tour could be just right.

This experience seems best suited for those who want a lively, educational, and delicious introduction to NYC’s pizza scene, with plenty of stories and a genuine taste of local favorites.

Key Points

• Authentic local experience: Visit up to five different pizzerias, many of which are beloved by locals but might be easy to miss alone.
• Educational insight: Learn fun facts and stories about New York’s pizza history and the Greenwich Village neighborhood.
• Small-group vibe: With a cap of 14 people, the tour maintains a personal atmosphere, making it easier to ask questions and connect.
• Generous lunch: All pizza slices are included, providing enough food for a hearty, casual lunch.
• Variety of styles: From classic slices to Detroit squares, the tour showcases different kinds of pizza, satisfying diverse tastes.
• Convenient timing: Starts at 12:30 pm, making it easy to incorporate into a midday stroll or explore other sights afterward.

The Full Breakdown: What You Can Expect

Starting Point and First Stop: The Budget Classic

The tour kicks off at 333 6th Ave, where you’ll get your first taste of New York’s most affordable slice—the famed 99-cent pizza. It’s a straightforward way to set the tone: simple, tasty, and affordable. For many, this slice hits the spot and reminds you of what makes NYC pizza iconic. We liked how this initial stop gives you a taste of the city’s everyday pizza culture rather than just upscale or trendy spots.

Second Stop: A Celebrity-Filled Gem on Carmine Street

Next, at 7 Carmine St, the focus shifts to a place that offers five different pies. Here, you’ll have the chance to compare styles and flavors, while soaking in the wall of celebrity photos and vintage signage. It’s a neighborhood favorite, with enough variety to keep your taste buds interested. Many reviews highlight the friendly atmosphere and the fact that all slices are included, making it feel like a value-packed lunch.

Third Stop: Larger Selection on 7th Avenue

Moving to 69 7th Ave S, this spot boasts a broader array of pies. It’s clear some of the places in this tour have become local legends, especially with their walls lined with celebrity photos — a common theme here. The variety means you might find a new favorite; some may prefer this larger selection over the previous spots. It’s also a good chance to see how different places approach the same classic dish.

Fourth Stop: Bustling Decor and Extra-Large Slices

At 111 MacDougal St, expect a busy, vibrant vibe with classic NYC decor. This place is known for its extra-large slices, perfect if you’re extra hungry or just want a slice that’s almost a meal on its own. The reviews mention the decor’s charm and the quality of the pizza, though whether this is the best in town is subjective. Still, it’s fun to see a place that’s truly buzzing with energy.

Final Stop: The Iconic Square Slice

The tour wraps up at 35 Downing St, where you’ll get to try a Detroit-style square slice. It’s a fun twist on the traditional and offers a different texture and flavor profile. This is a highlight for many because it’s a style often overlooked by travelers, giving you a broader perspective on NY’s pizza scene.

What’s Included and How It Works

The tour includes all slices—so you won’t need to pay extra at each stop. It’s designed to be a lunch rather than just a snack, so you’ll come away full and satisfied. The meeting point is centrally located on 6th Avenue, and the tour lasts around two hours, making it a manageable and enjoyable experience without feeling rushed.

The small-group size (max 14) means you’re likely to have a more intimate experience, with plenty of chances to ask questions or just chat with your guide. Plus, it’s all mobile ticketing, so no fuss there.

What the Reviews Say

The reviews are glowing—all five stars—with travelers praising the knowledgeable guides, the variety of pizza, and the friendly atmosphere. For example, one reviewer said, “No pizza was the same and was the perfect way to explore the pizza scene in New York,” highlighting how this tour offers a genuine taste of the city’s diverse pizza culture.

Another reviewer called the guide “super friendly and very knowledgeable,” which makes a big difference in such a small, interactive setting. Kids and families weren’t specifically mentioned, but many reviews point out how fun and engaging the experience was for all ages, especially if you’re traveling with a pizza-loving crew.

The value for money is also a common theme, with many saying that trying five different pizzerias plus learning about Greenwich Village is well worth the price.

Practical Details: What You Need to Know

• Price: $59 per person, which is quite reasonable for the amount of food and the guided experience
• Duration: About 2 hours, perfect for a midday activity
• Start Time: 12:30 pm, allowing for a relaxed lunch or to fit into a day of sightseeing
• Group Size: capped at 14 — so expect a friendly, less crowded atmosphere
• Accessibility: Near public transportation, and service animals are allowed
• Cancellation: Free cancellation up to 24 hours in advance

Who Should Book This Tour?

If you’re someone who loves pizza and wants to discover local favorites rather than tourist traps, this tour is a clever way to do both. It’s best suited for travelers who enjoy a casual, social experience and are happy to walk a bit through Greenwich Village. It also appeals to those who want a good mix of tasting and storytelling, especially if they’re interested in NYC’s culinary quirks.

While it’s not explicitly marketed as family-friendly, reviews suggest it’s a relaxed environment suitable for all ages, especially if your kids love pizza. Just keep in mind that it’s a walking tour, so small kids or those with mobility issues might want to plan accordingly.

Final Thoughts: Is It Worth It?

For pizza aficionados or anyone curious about Greenwich Village’s iconic slices, this tour delivers more than just pizza. It offers a window into NYC’s casual food culture, topped with stories, friendly guides, and a variety of styles that keep things interesting. The fact that many reviews mention the guides’ friendliness and knowledge suggests you’re in good hands.

At $59, this tour provides a generous lunch and plenty of bites, making it a solid value. It’s especially suitable if you want a relaxed, fun experience with a small group, learning about the neighborhood and its pizza scene without breaking the bank.

If you’re seeking a quick, tasty, and informative slice of New York life, this could be just the tour you’re looking for.

FAQ

Is this tour suitable for vegetarians?
While the exact menu details aren’t specified, you’ll visit a variety of places, so it’s likely some spots have vegetarian options. It’s worth asking the provider directly if you have specific dietary needs.

How many slices do I get to try?
You’ll visit up to five different pizzerias, and all slices are included in the price. This means a good number of slices, enough for a comfortable lunch.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, you can cancel for a full refund if you do so at least 24 hours before the start time. Cancellations within 24 hours aren’t eligible for a refund.

Is the tour walkable for all ages?
Most travelers can participate, and the tour involves walking through Greenwich Village. It’s suitable for most ages, but keep in mind it’s a two-hour walk, so plan accordingly.

Are pets allowed?
Service animals are permitted, but other pets probably aren’t, as it’s a walking tour visiting multiple restaurants.

What’s the starting point?
It begins at 323 6th Ave, New York, NY 10014, with the tour ending at 35 Downing St.

How much does it cost?
The tour is priced at $59 per person, which includes all tastings and the guide.

Is there an age limit?
The experience is open to most travelers, but it’s not specifically marketed as family-oriented. It’s best suited for adults and older kids who enjoy walking and pizza.

In the end, this tour seems like a tasty, friendly, and well-priced way to sample Greenwich Village’s pizza scene while learning a little about NYC’s culinary roots. Whether you’re a die-hard pizza fan or just looking for a fun local experience, it’s worth considering for your trip.