If you’re scoping out something different for your evening in the Pocono Mountains, Straight Up Magic could be just the ticket. This tour, hosted by Jason Bishop, is billed as “direct from Broadway,” and honestly, it lives up to that claim in terms of polish and professionalism. It’s a one-hour-and-20-minute spectacle packed with illusions, humor, and some genuine surprises.
What makes this experience particularly appealing is its accessibility—you don’t need to be a magic aficionado to enjoy it, just a love for good entertainment. Plus, the reviews are glowing, with a perfect 5 out of 5 based on 16 reviews, and everyone seems to agree that it’s a highlight in the Poconos.
That said, it’s not without its considerations. The ticket price is fair for what’s on offer, but you won’t get a dinner or full-scale show like a Las Vegas act; it’s more of a focused, intimate magic experience. It’s best suited for those seeking lighthearted fun or a unique night out without the hefty cost or long commitments.
If you’re after something different, engaging, and reliably entertaining during your Pocono trip, this show might be right up your alley. Here’s what you need to know before booking.
Key Points
- High-Quality Production: Hosted by Broadway-level magician Jason Bishop, known for his skill and humor.
- Engaging and Hilarious: Reviews highlight the show’s entertainment value and comedic moments.
- Accessible for Most: Most travelers can participate, and service animals are allowed.
- Short and Sweet: About 75 minutes long, making it easy to fit into your evening plans.
- Affordable: At $45 per person, it offers a good value for a highly-rated magic experience.
- Family-Friendly Considerations: Children under six aren’t permitted, so plan accordingly.
A Closer Look at the Experience
Let’s unpack what you actually get with this tour. The show is set at 309 Resort Dr, Tannersville, starting promptly at 7:30 pm. The venue feels intimate, and with a group size that can go up to 210, you’ll likely find yourself in a lively yet cozy setting.
The entire experience runs about 75 minutes, during which you’ll witness jaw-dropping acts of magic that seem almost impossible. The magic feats involve audience participation—some people even get to examine the props, like cinderblocks and wooden crates, just before they’re shattered or transformed before your eyes. That’s part of what makes the show so compelling; it’s not just watching illusions, but feeling like you’re part of the wonder.
Many of the reviews emphasize the humor and fun atmosphere. Katherine_B, for instance, noted, “Magic acts were great, entertaining and the humor very funny! We smiled, laughed and clapped throughout the entire show! Loved it!” That mix of amazement and comedy keeps things light and enjoyable, making it an ideal choice for a relaxed night out.
Planning more time in Pocono Mountains? We've covered other experiences worth considering.
What to Expect During the Show
Expect a fast-paced, energetic presentation packed with sleight of hand, illusions, and some unexpected surprises. The setup seems straightforward—audience members are brought into the act, and some even handle the props, adding an extra layer of authenticity and fun.
While specific tricks aren’t disclosed, the fact that audience members are invited to examine props beforehand suggests a level of transparency that’s rare in magic shows. It’s a clever way to build trust and amplify the surprise when the impossible happens.
What’s Included and What’s Not
The ticket price covers all fees and taxes, so you won’t have any surprise charges. Food and drinks aren’t included but are available for purchase—hot and cold food, soft drinks, and adult beverages. You might want to arrive a little early if you’re hungry or plan to have drinks during the show.
The meeting point is straightforward, and since most travelers can participate, it’s accessible for a wide audience. Service animals are also permitted, which is a thoughtful touch for travelers with pets.
Is This Tour Worth It?
Pricing at $45 per person strikes us as quite reasonable, considering the level of talent involved. You’re getting a show that’s been featured on NBC, CBS, and even international television, so it’s not just a run-of-the-mill local act. For the entertainment value, humor, and interactive magic you’ll experience, this is a solid deal.
The reviews underscore its value; Katherine described it as “amazing and hilarious,” and the fact that it’s recommended by every reviewer indicates that most guests find it well worth their time and money.
How the Tour Fits into Your Trip
If you’re looking for a memorable evening that’s different from the usual dining or outdoor activities, this show offers a welcome change. Its one-hour-and-20-minute duration makes it perfect for an after-dinner plan or as a standalone experience during your stay.
The show’s focus on engaging illusions and comedy makes it suitable for a broad audience, but do note children under six are not permitted—so it’s best suited for families with older kids or groups of adults.
Final Thoughts: Who Should Consider This Show?
This isn’t a magic show for die-hard magicians or illusion aficionados—rather, it’s designed for anyone who loves a good laugh and a bit of the extraordinary. If you enjoy lively performances that are both funny and astonishing, you’ll probably find this to be one of the best things to do in the Poconos.
Travelers looking for a fun, engaging, and reasonably priced evening activity will appreciate how smoothly everything runs and the caliber of the act. It’s perfect for those who want to see a professional, well-rated show without traveling all the way to NYC or Las Vegas.
However, if you’re seeking a full night of dining, or an experience with deep historical or cultural themes, this isn’t quite that. It’s all about entertainment, comedy, and awe—delivered with professionalism and a sense of humor.
Straight Up Magic in Tannersville Pennsylvania
“Magic acts were great, entertaining and the humor very funny! We smiled, laughed and clapped throughout the entire show! Loved it!”
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this experience suitable for children?
Children under six are not permitted, so it’s best for families with slightly older kids or groups of adults looking for fun.
How long does the show last?
The performance runs about 75 minutes, making it a perfect short evening activity.
What’s included in the ticket price?
All fees and taxes are included. Food and drinks are available separately for purchase but are not included.
Can I get a refund if I change my mind?
Yes, you can cancel for free up to 24 hours in advance, and you’ll receive a full refund. Cancellations less than 24 hours before the start aren’t refundable.
Is the show accessible for people with service animals?
Yes, service animals are allowed, making it accessible for travelers with disabilities.
What is the venue like?
The show starts and ends at the same meeting point in Tannersville, PA, in an environment that seems intimate and lively, with a maximum of 210 travelers.
Do I need to prepare anything before attending?
Not really—just arrive a little early if you want to settle in or grab a snack.
Are there group discounts?
The tour features group discounts, which can be a great way to see the show with friends or family.
What level of participation is expected?
Most travelers can participate; some audience members examine props before the tricks are performed, adding to the fun.
All in all, if you’re after a night of impressive illusions with plenty of laughs, Straight Up Magic offers a polished, highly-rated experience that won’t disappoint. It’s a good pick for a fun, memorable evening in the Pocono Mountains.