We Shall Overcome: A Williamsburg Black History Experience

If you’re heading to Williamsburg and want to deepen your understanding of Black history during the colonial era, this tour offers a compelling look at stories often missing from typical history lessons. It’s a focused journey that brings to light the lives, struggles, and resilience of African Americans in Williamsburg, blending historic sites with insightful narration.

What we really appreciate about this experience is how it balances historical depth with respectful storytelling. The guides are clearly passionate and well-informed, making complex and often heavy topics easier to engage with. Another highlight? It’s a walkable tour that stays mostly outdoors, letting you absorb the atmosphere of historic Williamsburg while learning about its Black residents.

However, a bit of a caveat: the tour can be emotionally heavy, especially if you’re sensitive to stories of slavery and oppression. One review even mentioned feeling overwhelmed and leaving early, so it’s not necessarily a light afternoon activity. Still, if you’re genuinely interested in a meaningful exploration of Black history, this tour could be a vital part of your Williamsburg visit.

This experience is best suited for history buffs, anyone curious about untold stories, and travelers who appreciate authentic, well-researched narratives. It’s not a casual or family-friendly sightseeing tour, but for those ready for an honest and thorough look into a crucial part of American history, it’s worth considering.

Key Points

• Authentic insights into Black history in Williamsburg beyond the usual stories
• Detailed stops at historic sites with mostly outside visits and occasional inside access
• Highly praised guides known for their knowledge and sensitivity
• Affordable price point considering the depth of information and guided experience
• Emotionally impactful, so prepare for heavy topics
• Limited indoor access, so good footwear and weather readiness are recommended

A Closer Look at the Itinerary

This tour runs for about two hours and takes you through key historic spots in Williamsburg, each offering a different perspective on Black history. It’s a walking tour, so be prepared for some outdoor time, and since it’s mostly outside, good shoes and weather-appropriate clothing are essential.

Stop 1: The Historic First Baptist Church-Nassau Street Archaeology Project

This first stop introduces the church that was pivotal for African Americans in Williamsburg, especially as it was attended by slave owners. It’s a chance to see the graves of some slaves buried in the church’s yard, providing a visceral connection to the past.

Bonus inside visit: Limited to certain days (Monday, Wednesday, Friday, Saturday), and only if available. A quick 10-minute look inside the church can be quite impactful, especially if you get the chance.

What travelers say: One reviewer highlighted how the church’s history was a stark reminder of the buried stories of those enslaved here. It sets a serious tone but a necessary one for understanding the depth of the history.

Stop 2: Brickhouse Tavern Williamsburg

Now a lively tavern, this historic building once held the first African American lawyer’s office. It’s a neat example of how Williamsburg’s history is layered, showing moments of breakthrough amid the oppressive context.

Note: The tour only stays outside here, so don’t expect a tour inside, but the exterior provides plenty of context.

Review insight: Visitors appreciated learning about the barrier-breaking figure who was associated with this site. It’s a quick stop but adds an important dimension to the narrative.

Stop 3: George Wythe House

This house belonged to George Wythe, a notable figure who owned slaves but also played a role in revolutionary Virginia. The story here is complex—loyal slaves discovering a plot against Wythe adds a human element to the history.

Outside visit: Again, only the exterior is included, but it’s meaningful to see where these stories unfolded.

What travelers say: The outside view, coupled with the guide’s storytelling, makes this a compelling stop that highlights the complicated relationships of that era.

Stop 4: Governor’s Palace

During the Revolution, debate over slavery was front and center. Lord Dunmore’s proclamation offering freedom to slaves who fought for the British was a game-changer, and this stop helps you understand that pivotal moment.

Outside only: It’s about taking in the atmosphere and understanding the political debates happening then.

Stop 5: Peyton Randolph House

This site reveals the stark reality of slave ownership among colonists. One insightful story involves the lady of the house, whose ownership of slaves was typical for her time but sheds light on the attitudes of the period.

Review highlight: Travelers found this stop revealing about the ownership and attitudes toward slavery in Williamsburg.

Stop 6: Raleigh Tavern

This is where colonists responded to Lord Dunmore’s proclamation. It’s a short walk that offers a glimpse into revolutionary debates about slavery and liberty.

Stop 7: Mary Stith House

A standout in the tour, this house belonged to a woman who was “ahead of her time.” She left her estate to her freed Black servants, a remarkable act of kindness and equality for the period.

What you’ll love: The story of Mary Stith underscores that some individuals in Williamsburg saw beyond the era’s prevalent prejudices.

Stop 8: Colonial Williamsburg Courthouse

Here, the process of buying and fleeing with slaves is explored, along with efforts to recover fugitive slaves. It’s a sobering but important reminder of the systemic nature of slavery.

What Makes This Tour Stand Out

The tour’s most praised aspect is the depth of knowledge and sensitivity of the guides. Multiple reviews specifically mention how well-informed and compassionate the guides are, which truly enhances the experience. The fact that most stops are outside allows you to soak in the historic ambiance—walking past authentic buildings, feeling the weight of history in the air.

Price-wise, at just $23.25 per person, it’s an accessible way to gain a meaningful perspective on Black history in Williamsburg. The guide’s preparation and the accuracy of the stories ensure you’re getting value that extends beyond superficial sightseeing.

Walking and Group Size

With a maximum of 20 travelers, it’s a small group setting, which lends itself to a more personal and engaging experience. The tour begins at the Kimball Theatre, making it easy to find and meet up with your guide.

Time and Duration

At just about two hours, it’s a manageable commitment that fits well into a day of sightseeing. Since transportation isn’t included, be sure to arrive ready to walk and equipped for outdoor conditions.

Authenticity and Reviews

Reviews span from extremely positive to some disappointed, mainly relating to expectations and emotional weight. Many travelers emphasize how the guide’s honesty and knowledge made the experience memorable and impactful. Several reviews note that the tour covers stories of love, resilience, and hope—highlighting the human side of history.

One reviewer spoke about the importance of hearing the stories of Black Americans as part of American history itself, which is exactly what this tour aims to do. Others mention the authentic atmosphere and the opportunity to ask questions, making it a truly educational experience.

A few travelers did mention moments of emotional distress, especially with the heavy topics, but overall, the tour’s honesty and depth are what attract most people.

The Value for Your Trip

At this price point, you’re paying for a well-researched, guided journey that offers more than just surface-level history. You’ll walk through historically significant sites, hear stories that often go untold, and gain a better understanding of Williamsburg’s complex past. The guides’ ability to handle sensitive topics with respect and candor adds to the experience’s authenticity.

It’s not a tour that shies away from the difficult truths, but rather confronts them head-on. For those interested in a respectful, honest, and enlightening exploration of Black history in colonial Williamsburg, this tour offers great value.

The Sum Up

If you’re looking for an experience that goes beyond typical sightseeing and offers genuine insights into a crucial part of American history, We Shall Overcome: A Williamsburg Black History Experience is a strong choice. It’s especially suited for those who value knowledgeable guides, authentic historic sites, and stories of resilience and struggle.

While it may be emotionally challenging for some, this tour provides a valuable perspective that could reshape how you see Williamsburg and its role in American history. Its affordability makes it accessible without sacrificing depth or quality—making it a meaningful addition to any Williamsburg itinerary.

For travelers eager to connect historical dots and honor untold stories, this tour provides an honest look at the past that’s both educational and moving.

FAQ

Is transportation included in this tour?
No, transportation is not included. The tour begins at the Kimball Theatre and you’ll walk between stops.

How long does the tour last?
It lasts approximately 2 hours, making it a focused and manageable walk.

Can I visit inside the historic sites during the tour?
Most stops are outside, but there’s an optional 10-minute inside visit at the First Baptist Church, available on certain days if space permits.

Is this tour suitable for families or children?
The tour covers heavy topics related to slavery and oppression, so it may be more suitable for older teens and adults who can handle sensitive material.

What is the price per person?
The tour costs $23.25 per person, offering a cost-effective way to dive into Black Williamsburg history with expert guides.

How far in advance should I book?
On average, the tour is booked 12 days in advance, so it’s best to plan ahead, especially during peak seasons.

What is the group size?
A maximum of 20 travelers, which allows for a more personal and engaging experience.

Are service animals allowed?
Yes, service animals are permitted on the tour.

What if I need to cancel?
You can cancel free of charge up to 24 hours before the tour starts for a full refund.

What kind of reviews has this tour received?
It has a strong overall rating of 4.7 out of 5 based on 52 reviews, with many travelers praising the knowledge, sensitivity, and impactful stories shared by guides.