If you’re visiting New York City and crave something beyond the usual skyline views and bustling streets, the Catacombs by Candlelight tour offers a unique peek beneath the city’s surface. We haven’t personally taken this particular tour, but from what’s shared and the glowing reviews, it’s a compelling way to connect with the city’s Catholic past—and to do so in a setting that feels like stepping into a secret world.
What makes this experience stand out? First, it’s the exclusive access to areas normally off-limits, including two historic cemeteries and the active catacombs — a rare find in a city famed for its architectural marvels. Second, the knowledge and enthusiasm of the guides consistently shine through in reviews, making the tour not only informative but also entertaining.
One thing to keep in mind is that the tour lasts about 1.5 hours, which is enough to feel like you’ve uncovered a genuine slice of history without it dragging on. However, it’s not fully wheelchair accessible, thanks to a staircase leading down into the catacomb area. This is an important consideration if you’re traveling with mobility challenges.
The Catacombs by Candlelight appeals most to history buffs, those curious about religious or local history, or anyone looking for a different kind of NYC experience. Even if you’re not a devout Catholic, the stories of the prominent Americans buried there make it worthwhile.
Key Points
- Exclusive Access: You get to explore parts of the church grounds normally closed to the public, including two old cemeteries.
- Historical Depth: The tour highlights the resting places of notable figures like bishops, politicians, and Civil War generals.
- Guides Matter: Several reviews praise knowledgeable, engaging guides who make the history come alive.
- Atmosphere: The candlelight creates a quiet, reverent mood that enhances the experience.
- Practical Details: The tour lasts about 1.5 hours, costs $38, and is wheelchair accessible, but involves a staircase.
- Respectful Environment: As an active parish, visitors are expected to be respectful at all times.
An Inside Look at the Tour Experience
The tour begins at 266 Mulberry Street, right at the corner of Jersey Street, in the heart of Little Italy. This location is vital to note because it’s not the famous St. Patrick’s Cathedral on Fifth Avenue, but the older Basilica of St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral, which has its own charm and history. The check-in process is straightforward, and the small group setting means you’re unlikely to feel lost in a crowd.
Once the tour kicks off, your guide immediately sets a respectful tone, emphasizing the historical significance of the site. From there, you’ll be led into the church’s historic grounds and the two secret cemeteries, both closed to the public otherwise. Walking through these spaces at night, lit only by tea lights, lends a sense of solemnity and curiosity. You’ll see the graves of many high-profile Americans, including prominent Catholics like the Delmonico family and the first resident Bishop of New York, Bishop John Connolly.
The highlight, however, is undoubtedly the active Catholic catacombs, a rare sight in NYC. These vaults contain the remains of notable figures, including bishops, civil war generals, and industry leaders. The stories behind these graves add a layer of fascination—reviewers frequently mention how guides weave in anecdotes about the individuals buried there, making it more than just a walk through a crypt.
The experience is designed to be respectful and contemplative, with tea lights adding a gentle glow to the dark corridors. Many reviewers mention how the atmosphere feels “serene,” “calm,” and even “pre-Halloween,” thanks to the flickering flame and quiet setting. One reviewer noted that the guide was not only knowledgeable but also entertaining, which helps keep the mood engaging without being creepy.
While the vaults themselves are sealed, the stories about the prominent figures buried there, such as Civil War-era generals or wealthy merchants, are what make this tour meaningful. You’ll learn that the vaults belong largely to influential New Yorkers, and the guide shares insights into their lives and contributions.
Guide Quality and Educational Value
The reviews are filled with praise for the guides—many describe them as passionate, knowledgeable, and personable. For example, one said, “Our guide was extremely knowledgeable, passionate, and personable,” while another loved how a guide drew everyone in with “a wealth of information” and humor.
Guides don’t just recite facts—they tell stories that make history feel alive. For instance, some mention how guides explain the land acquisition for the church or the defenses during Protestant attacks, providing context that enhances the experience.
The guides also handle questions well, ensuring everyone leaves with a good understanding of the site’s significance. This interactive element is appreciated, especially since some reviews note the tour’s short duration—most say it’s just the right length for a meaningful visit.
The Value for Money
At $38 per person, this tour offers a reasonably priced window into a seldom-seen side of NYC. Given the exclusive access, the engaging storytelling, and the atmospheric setting, many reviews agree it’s good value. It’s a niche experience that’s hard to find elsewhere in the city, making it well worth the price if you’re interested in history, architecture, or religious sites.
The inclusion of tea lights and a professional guide enhances the experience, and the small-group environment means you’re likely to enjoy a more personalized tour. However, keep in mind that gratuities are not included, so if you’re happy with the guide’s effort, a tip is a nice gesture.
Practical Considerations
- Duration: 1.5 hours, generally available in the morning and afternoon.
- Meeting Point: 266 Mulberry Street, close to Little Italy’s heart.
- Accessibility: Not fully wheelchair accessible due to a staircase, but the tour is otherwise wheelchair friendly.
- Clothing & Shoes: Wear comfortable shoes—there’s some walking on uneven surfaces, and the stairs are unavoidable.
- What to Bring: Cash for tips (if desired), weather-appropriate clothing, and perhaps a small flashlight if you want to see every nook.
- Restrictions: No shorts or sleeveless shirts, and video recording isn’t allowed.
- Respect: As an active church, reverence is expected throughout.
Who Will Love This Tour?
This experience is perfect for those who appreciate history, architecture, or religious sites. It’s especially appealing if you enjoy stories of notable historical figures or want to explore New York beyond its well-trodden tourist spots. Families with older children may find it intriguing, especially those interested in history or ghost stories, but it’s not suited to wheelchair users or those over 80 due to stairs.
Expect a quiet, respectful atmosphere where you can learn about the lives and deaths of influential New Yorkers in a setting that feels both solemn and fascinating. It’s a memorable way to experience the city’s layered past, told through the lens of those who shaped it.
FAQ — Practical Answers to Common Questions
Is this tour suitable for children?
While older kids who are interested in history or ghost stories might enjoy it, younger children or those sensitive to dark, quiet environments may find it less engaging or a bit spooky.
How long is the tour?
It lasts about 1.5 hours, which is just enough time to explore the key areas without feeling rushed.
Is the tour wheelchair accessible?
It is not fully wheelchair accessible due to a staircase leading into the catacomb area, but generally, the rest of the tour is accessible.
What should I wear?
Wear comfortable shoes suitable for walking and weather-appropriate clothing as part of the tour takes place outdoors or in cool, shaded areas.
Can I record videos during the tour?
Video recording isn’t allowed, likely out of respect for the active parish and the solemn environment.
What’s included in the price?
The tour includes a professional guide and complimentary tea lights to set the mood during your walk.
Is there a dress code?
As it’s a church site, avoid shorts and sleeveless shirts out of respect for the religious setting.
When can I join the tour?
Most tours are available in the morning and afternoon, but check ahead for specific times and availability.
Are tips included?
Tips for guides are not included, so if you’re pleased with the experience, a gratuity is appreciated.
What if I need to cancel?
You can cancel up to 2 hours in advance for a full refund, making this a flexible option.
New York City: Catacombs by Candlelight
Final Thoughts
The New York City: Catacombs by Candlelight tour offers a distinctive blend of history, atmosphere, and storytelling that’s hard to match elsewhere in the city. For those who love uncovering lesser-known stories, exploring historic cemeteries, or simply seeking a different perspective on NYC, this experience delivers.
It’s especially suitable for history enthusiasts, architecture buffs, or travelers looking for a quiet, respectful reflection on the city’s past. The knowledgeable guides, the serene candlelit ambiance, and the chance to see areas normally closed to the public make it a memorable addition to your NYC itinerary.
While it’s not the most accessible tour or suited for everyone, its value lies in its authenticity and the intimate connection it fosters with the city’s history. It’s not a large-scale spectacle but a personal journey into one of NYC’s quieter, more contemplative corners.
If you’re prepared for a short walk, an atmosphere of reverence, and a thirst for stories about influential Americans long gone, this tour could be a highlight of your trip.
You can check availability for your dates here: