Exploring NYC’s Shadowy Past: The Outlaws Who Built NYC Walking Tour
If you’re interested in the darker, less-glamorous side of New York City’s history, then the Outlaws Who Built NYC Walking Tour might just be your new favorite way to uncover the city’s hidden stories. This tour promises to take you through the streets where con artists, gangsters, pirates, and corrupt lawmen once thrived—an angle of NYC history that’s often overlooked in traditional guides.
What we love about this experience is how it combines storytelling with walking, giving a real sense of place and history. First, the knowledgeable guides bring these stories to life, making the past both vivid and engaging. Second, the stunning views, especially of iconic landmarks like the Brooklyn Bridge, add a visual backdrop to the tales of corruption and crime. But a noteworthy consideration is that the tour covers a lot of ground in just two hours, so it’s fast-paced, and you may want to be prepared for some walking and standing.
This tour is ideal for history buffs, curious travelers, or anyone who likes stories of the city’s shady side. It’s also well-suited for those who want to see parts of Manhattan they might not encounter on typical sightseeing routes. If you’re into discovering how the city’s wealth and power were built on secrets and scandal, this is likely to be a memorable addition to your NYC itinerary.
Key Points

- Unique Focus: Highlights the criminal and shady aspects of New York City’s history, setting it apart from more standard tours.
- Expert Guides: Guides are described as very well-informed and enthusiastic, making the stories come alive.
- Great Value: At $32, it offers an affordable way to learn about the city’s darker past in a manageable time frame.
- Short and Sweet: The 2-hour walking format fits well into a busy schedule while providing a thorough glimpse into NYC’s underground history.
- Rich Stories: Tour features tales of pirates, racketeers, police corruption, and influential outlaws like Captain Kidd.
- Stunning Views: The tour includes stops at iconic spots like the Brooklyn Bridge and the Financial District, offering both history and scenery.
A Deep Dive into the Experience

If you're drawn to exploring New York City on foot, we've looked into these other walking experiences
The Introductory Meet-Up and First Impressions
Starting outside the Millennium Downtown New York hotel, the meeting point feels central and accessible, close to major transit options. The group size maxes out at 15, which keeps things intimate and allows for a more personal experience. Your guide, Krombie, is praised for her energy and depth of knowledge, adding a layer of enthusiasm that keeps the tour lively.
What You’ll See and Learn
From the very beginning, this tour sets out to reveal stories most travelers never hear. The first stop at Lower Manhattan introduces you to the area’s early days, with a focus on the privateers and pirates who once roamed nearby waters. You might find it fascinating to discover how pirates like Captain Kidd are tied to city landmarks, blending legend with history in a way that makes the stories feel real.
Moving on, the tour touches on the secret remedies and underground trades that rewired NYC’s future—an intriguing piece of the city’s shadow economy. Stops at places like the Oculus World Trade Center and the 9/11 Memorial & Museum serve as anchors for stories about the city’s evolution from pirate haven to financial powerhouse, all while hinting at the shady dealings behind the scenes.
The Heart of the Tour: Crime and Corruption in the Financial District
One of the most compelling parts is walking through Wall Street, where tales of the 1920 bombing and the banking roots of the city laid a foundation rife with crime and greed. The stories of police corruption in the 1970s, and the links to notorious outlaws like Captain Kidd, show how crime intertwined with the city’s growth.
You’ll also visit the site of the First Precinct, where the dark history of law enforcement and organized crime come together, illustrating that the city’s legal system was often as shady as the criminals it was supposed to fight. The White Horse Tavern, once home to city lawbreakers, adds a fitting historical ambiance.
The Views and Atmosphere
Throughout, the tour offers the chance to stand at spots like the East River Waterfront Esplanade for a birds-eye view of Brooklyn Bridge, discussing its corrupt beginnings—another example of how appearances often masked darker stories. The scenery complements the storytelling, giving you both visual and historical context.
Authenticity and Reviews
People who’ve taken this tour consistently praise the knowledge, enthusiasm, and storytelling skills of the guides. One reviewer called Krombie “a terrific tour guide—very excited about the topic and very well informed,” which is exactly what you want when exploring such niche history. Several mention the unique nature of the tour and how it goes beyond the usual Manhattan attractions to reveal stories and sites they hadn’t heard before.
The value for money is also highlighted, especially given the short duration and the depth of stories packed into two hours. The reviews suggest that you’ll come away with a fascinating perspective on how crime, corruption, and daring exploits shaped modern NYC.
Practical Details
The tour costs $32 per person—an accessible price for such a focused, guided experience. It’s scheduled to start at 3:00 pm, perfect for an afternoon stroll. The walking is manageable and the stops are brief, with most lasting around 6 to 8 minutes, which keeps the pace brisk but digestible.
Reservations include a mobile ticket, and cancellation is free up to 24 hours before the start, making it flexible for travelers with changing plans. The tour is suitable for most travelers, with service animals permitted, and it’s designed to be engaging even for those unfamiliar with the city’s more unsavory past.
The Bottom Line

This tour offers a compelling look at New York City through a different lens—one that reveals the city’s connections to pirates, gangsters, and corrupt lawmen. You’ll learn about the stories behind the landmarks you see every day, adding layers of intrigue and history to your visit.
If you’re someone who enjoys stories of adventure, scandal, and the city’s underground economy, this tour will satisfy your curiosity. It’s an especially good choice if you want a quick, affordable, and engaging way to see parts of Manhattan that are often overlooked in traditional sightseeing tours.
The knowledgeable guides and well-structured itinerary ensure you won’t just walk and listen—you’ll come away with a richer understanding of NYC’s complex, at times shady, evolutionary path. Plus, the scenic views and iconic sites give it a nice balance of history and scenery.
However, keep in mind that the tour is quite fast-paced, so if you prefer a slow, relaxed stroll with lots of time to soak in each stop, this might feel rushed. Still, for those seeking a fun, eye-opening journey into the city’s secretive past, this is a worthwhile experience.
The Outlaws Who Built NYC Walking Tour
“Krombie was a terrific tour guide – very excited about the topic and very well informed. We really enjoyed our time with her learning about pirates…”
FAQs

Is this tour suitable for children?
The tour is aimed at general audiences and involves walking and standing for about two hours, so it might be best for older children or teenagers interested in history and storytelling.
How long does the tour last?
Approximately 2 hours, covering multiple stops around Lower Manhattan and the Financial District.
What is the price of the tour?
It costs $32 per person, which provides good value considering the guided storytelling and access to historic sites.
Where does the tour start and end?
It begins outside the Millennium Downtown New York hotel and ends at the White Horse Tavern on Bridge Street.
Are tickets available on the day of the tour?
While not explicitly stated, most reservations are made in advance, and mobile tickets are provided. It’s recommended to book ahead to secure a spot.
Can I cancel the tour?
Yes, cancellations are free up to 24 hours before the start time, allowing flexibility if your plans change.
Is this tour accessible by public transportation?
Yes, the meeting point is very close to various subway stations and ferry services, making it easy to reach.
Overall, the Outlaws Who Built NYC Walking Tour offers a punchy, interesting, and unique peek into the city’s shady past. It’s perfect for history buffs, curious explorers, and anyone eager to see NYC through a different lens—the stories behind the skyscrapers and the streets that built the city we know today.
More Walking Tours in New York City
- Sunday Walking Tour and Gospel in West Harlem
- Private The Village – NYC Walking Tour
- NYC Midtown Manhattan Highlights Private Walking Tour
- Highlights of Central Park New York City Guided Walking Tour
- Brooklyn: Dyker Heights Christmas Walking Tour
- East Village Donut and Pastry Adventure and Walking Food Tour
More Tours in New York City
More Tour Reviews in New York City
More New York City experiences we've covered
- Central Park Secrets And Highlights
- NYC Panoramic: Brooklyn and New Jersey Waterfront Night Tour
- Central Park Bike Tour
- NYC: Sunset Jazz Sail aboard the ‘Clipper City’
- Oh Mary! on Broadway Ticket
- Sunday Walking Tour and Gospel in West Harlem
- NYC: Empire State Horses Carriage Ride in Central Park
- NYC: Private Luxury Tour of NYC With Transportation
- From Westchester: New York City Scenic Helicopter Tour
- Private The Village – NYC Walking Tour
- 6 Iconic Audio Tours & City Guide App plus AI Question + Answer
- New York City: Smallpox Hospital Photo Tour
